Size or Speed?
#51
Fork Horn
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 201
Likes: 0
From: Central Indiana
Tom,
My equipment is:
My White rifles ranging from a Super Safari in .451 to a Bison in .540 with a couple .504s in between and quite possibly another .451 coming soon.
Then I have my Knight rifles, all early mk-85s and built back when quality was job one at Knight.
Topped off with a Lyman GPR in .54.
Every one of these guns is very accurate and has a bore as good as new and there isn't an animal in North America that I would be lacking in equipment to hunt.
I have owned a couple of disc rifles and they were both very nice to look at and accurate as can be but after shooting the conicals exclusively for a couple years I just don't feel like shooting saboted bullets any more. It just doesn't trip my trigger so to speak. Just a personal thing I guess.
As far as reality goes, your reality is different from mine. I respect yours, You otta respect mine.
Art
My equipment is:
My White rifles ranging from a Super Safari in .451 to a Bison in .540 with a couple .504s in between and quite possibly another .451 coming soon.
Then I have my Knight rifles, all early mk-85s and built back when quality was job one at Knight.
Topped off with a Lyman GPR in .54.
Every one of these guns is very accurate and has a bore as good as new and there isn't an animal in North America that I would be lacking in equipment to hunt.
I have owned a couple of disc rifles and they were both very nice to look at and accurate as can be but after shooting the conicals exclusively for a couple years I just don't feel like shooting saboted bullets any more. It just doesn't trip my trigger so to speak. Just a personal thing I guess.
As far as reality goes, your reality is different from mine. I respect yours, You otta respect mine.
Art
#52
mike
#53
Nontypical Buck
Joined: Mar 2009
Posts: 3,926
Likes: 0
From: Saxonburg Pa
Tom,
My equipment is:
My White rifles ranging from a Super Safari in .451 to a Bison in .540 with a couple .504s in between and quite possibly another .451 coming soon.
Then I have my Knight rifles, all early mk-85s and built back when quality was job one at Knight.
Topped off with a Lyman GPR in .54.
Every one of these guns is very accurate and has a bore as good as new and there isn't an animal in North America that I would be lacking in equipment to hunt.
I have owned a couple of disc rifles and they were both very nice to look at and accurate as can be but after shooting the conicals exclusively for a couple years I just don't feel like shooting saboted bullets any more. It just doesn't trip my trigger so to speak. Just a personal thing I guess.
As far as reality goes, your reality is different from mine. I respect yours, You otta respect mine.
Art
My equipment is:
My White rifles ranging from a Super Safari in .451 to a Bison in .540 with a couple .504s in between and quite possibly another .451 coming soon.
Then I have my Knight rifles, all early mk-85s and built back when quality was job one at Knight.
Topped off with a Lyman GPR in .54.
Every one of these guns is very accurate and has a bore as good as new and there isn't an animal in North America that I would be lacking in equipment to hunt.
I have owned a couple of disc rifles and they were both very nice to look at and accurate as can be but after shooting the conicals exclusively for a couple years I just don't feel like shooting saboted bullets any more. It just doesn't trip my trigger so to speak. Just a personal thing I guess.
As far as reality goes, your reality is different from mine. I respect yours, You otta respect mine.
Art
The internet can be very difficult to communicate sometimes. I try but always fail at it. And i do respect your choices. I don't care what you shoot, you don't care what i shoot.
I try to give information or debate information for the people that don't post. You seem to own alot of White rifles. I think i shot most of them over a couple years in TN. They were all great ML'S, and they all had to be tweaked. I remember Bob Bowers and Underclock years ago bitching about them. I don't even remember but it all happened on HA. My point is just like Encores the Whites needed tweaked as well.
Conical bullets were with out doubt, the worst bullets i have ever seen on Hogs. I watched this for a few years not days. I have never had good success with them in my Flintlock on Deer size game either. If you read the article in Black Powder hunting fall 2005 it talks about some of the multiple shot kills with conicals. Have they changed since 2005????? Dont get me wrong, i know there are plenty bad saboted bullets as well.
I have shot a lot of different bullets, and have watched a lot of animals killed over the years. I have found the Lehigh to be the best by far over any other bullet. That is my findings with well over 25 kills with them. Is there a better bullet? Maybe, i just have not used it yet, or saw someone else using it.
You also mentioned Knight Rifles above. They really got off track on a lot of things. The Super Disc, Extreme, and the Elite had huge gaps in tolerances. I should also mention the LRH as well. That stuff is just in excusable to me.
I was asked the other day why i said the Triumph is better then the Vision. The answer was because it is. Out of the box it is. Here again my opinions only.
I can promise you one thing, i dont say anything just to get something for free. I say it because it is what i have found. If Knight doesn't like it, or Lehigh sorry that's the way it is. You would not believe what i tell them actually. And to be honest they all listen.
flounder33, we have differences no doubt. Adults will decide what's best for them no matter how right or wrong we are.
#55
knight is one great guns but all the guns i have all have to have some twicking needed to be done to them to shot better even some custom gun i have needed some twicking all guns out of the box to me needs twiching but to you it my be fine that just me
#56
Nontypical Buck
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 2,496
Likes: 0
From: Yucca Valley,Ca
XXX2 on that. i have shot deer elk and hogs with a .430 gr T/C maxi from my .54 renegade and can tell you the total devastation that bullet had on those animals was a sight to behold.i have not shot any animal with a NE or BS conical as of yet, but knowing the overall quality is better on these bullets, along with it's larger metplate and seeing results from people shooting these bullets from 25-225 yds. i have no doubt there a better bullet than the maxi.conicals can do whatever any whiz bang bullet is capable of doing and at longer ranges probably better..Ray
#57
Nontypical Buck
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 2,496
Likes: 0
From: Yucca Valley,Ca
Grouse, i don't know what conicals you used on hogs. i can only assume your horrible luck with them was with a hollow point conical at close range.i have shot hogs here in cali with T/C maxi's with nothing but 100% total success and devastation.with a NE/BS i would expect even better performance on hogs, although dead is dead! as far as Lehighs are concerned, from the little i have seen they are no better than a Barnes expander MZ or TEZ in the terminal performance arena. both of these bullets are totally devastating on whatever animal one chooses to shoot with them. and i have never been able to find one sentence stating otherwise anywhere on the internet.i also feel for those longer shots the TEZ with it's poly tip and huge hollow point in .250 or .295 is a better choice than comparable weight lehighs due to better aerodynamics.i would shoot hogs all day any day with a .400 -.460 gr NE/BS or the mentioned Barnes bullets and with proper placed shots all would be stone dead, just as dead as being hit with a Lehigh.. Ray
#58
Nontypical Buck
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 2,496
Likes: 0
From: Yucca Valley,Ca
RB for that matter.any animal shot with either would be dead long before any shot could be heard. Ray
#60
Fork Horn
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 201
Likes: 0
From: Central Indiana
Okay..I won't. 
The Whites Rich and Bob were complaining about was the Thunderbolt model. There were serious design flaws in that rifle. Kudos to UC and Bob for all the work they did in trying to revive a dead horse. Their input definately helped,,,somewhat.
There are a few models of White rifles still available for folks who are looking for them.
C'mon Tom........seriously??

The Whites Rich and Bob were complaining about was the Thunderbolt model. There were serious design flaws in that rifle. Kudos to UC and Bob for all the work they did in trying to revive a dead horse. Their input definately helped,,,somewhat.
There are a few models of White rifles still available for folks who are looking for them.
C'mon Tom........seriously??
Last edited by batchief909; 04-25-2011 at 07:31 PM.



