goex olde eynsford bp
#11
Thread Starter
Nontypical Buck
Joined: Aug 2014
Posts: 1,168
Likes: 0
From: gilbert az
I'm suspicious that OE is a true black powder. I think something is added to give it the extra power. It doesn't feel like BP or even sound like BP when shot. It feels more like a sub and quite different to Swiss.
How it can compete with Swiss while being $10lb cheaper also makes me suspicious.
How it can compete with Swiss while being $10lb cheaper also makes me suspicious.
#12
I only bought OE once. It was only $1.00 more than regular Goex and I paid $16lb for OE. Swiss at the time was $25.95.
I see now they raised the price of OE to $18.59. So, it isn't $10 cheaper anymore. Maybe someone can explain how they added the extra power for what was originally just $1.00 lb more in price? Now it's still just $1.50 more than Goex. What do they bother to even make the regular Goex anymore? I think they do for those who want real black powder. I know Swiss gets a lot more time processing it and it uses the best alder wood for charcoal. It's the reason it cost more. What is Hodgden doing to make OE equal to Swiss and only has to charge $1.50 more? Something isn't right.
I see now they raised the price of OE to $18.59. So, it isn't $10 cheaper anymore. Maybe someone can explain how they added the extra power for what was originally just $1.00 lb more in price? Now it's still just $1.50 more than Goex. What do they bother to even make the regular Goex anymore? I think they do for those who want real black powder. I know Swiss gets a lot more time processing it and it uses the best alder wood for charcoal. It's the reason it cost more. What is Hodgden doing to make OE equal to Swiss and only has to charge $1.50 more? Something isn't right.
#13
Consistency often times results in more power. If you have kernel size all over the place like a LOT of BP, then you will have much less burn rate. OE is very consistent in their size of kernels much like Swiss is.
Pete, I have a feeling the reason OE is cheaper is because it isn't shipped in to the US so it doesn't have as much cost overhead like Swiss does.
As far as comparisons, I've used both and have found them pretty much equal except for cleanup. Swiss wins hands down there. But Swiss is a hell of a lot easier to find though! OE has a tendency to be under shipped to stores for some reason. Maybe popularity hasn't caught up to it's performance?
Pete, I have a feeling the reason OE is cheaper is because it isn't shipped in to the US so it doesn't have as much cost overhead like Swiss does.
As far as comparisons, I've used both and have found them pretty much equal except for cleanup. Swiss wins hands down there. But Swiss is a hell of a lot easier to find though! OE has a tendency to be under shipped to stores for some reason. Maybe popularity hasn't caught up to it's performance?
#15
Others don't agree with that. Graf's powder is Schuetzen and many say it burns cleaner than Goex. I agree. Goex is the dirtiest powder I ever shot. What is it in OE that makes it cleaner than Goex?
#16
Banned
Joined: Dec 2008
Posts: 9,186
Likes: 0
From: Boncarbo,Colorado
Most likely the charcoal difference they use.
I even found my old reports about accuracy and how dirty the shutz was. I had been using mrflintlock lube and the balls were getting caught up in the fouling during reloading. Thats not clean powder.
All the right hand shots were with the rifles normal load and shuetz powder. Thats not accurate at 50 yards. Even in my rifle, anything over 90gr wasnt worth the lead.
I even found my old reports about accuracy and how dirty the shutz was. I had been using mrflintlock lube and the balls were getting caught up in the fouling during reloading. Thats not clean powder.
All the right hand shots were with the rifles normal load and shuetz powder. Thats not accurate at 50 yards. Even in my rifle, anything over 90gr wasnt worth the lead.
#20
Swiss is dirty yes, but to say it's dirtier than Pyrodex is pure blasphemy Pete!!!
OE is just a bit dirtier than Swiss but not by much that I could tell the few times I used it.
MD is probably correct as to why it's priced the way it is Pete. And if you look at shipping overseas and hazmat charges and such you will see why it's so much cheaper than Swiss. I've no clue why OE is only marginally more expensive than reg Goex other than they just have a good mark up on Goex and don't charge such a high mark up on OE. If they did, then they wouldn't sell much because if they were close in price comparison to the better known Swiss people wouldn't buy it.
OE is just a bit dirtier than Swiss but not by much that I could tell the few times I used it. MD is probably correct as to why it's priced the way it is Pete. And if you look at shipping overseas and hazmat charges and such you will see why it's so much cheaper than Swiss. I've no clue why OE is only marginally more expensive than reg Goex other than they just have a good mark up on Goex and don't charge such a high mark up on OE. If they did, then they wouldn't sell much because if they were close in price comparison to the better known Swiss people wouldn't buy it.


