either!

Id rather have A but if your luck is anything like mine the past couple years... then shoot whichever you get a good shot at first and just hope the other one is around next season.

Typically between those age classes, you get a bigger anterled deer at 5 1/2, but I think most of us judge a true trophy by antler size rather than age.

A

I would have to say a-150 class. But the buck would no doubt be bigger the next year. Sorry to say but chance`s are! You would most likely not get another chance at him again, due to hunting pressure, maby even spooking out of the area, ULESS? you new where his bedding area was and you new his travel habbits,fedding bedding and very little hunting pressure ect. But just between us i would be happy with a 150 class anytime

YUP.... I can't count that high. Whichever one shows up first wins.[:-] If the other one shows up right after... we have "Co-champions".

I would shoot the one that afforded me the best shot. As niether of those deer are record book deer, I would shoot the one with the biggest body. If both bodies were equal, then I would have to say A.

Oh man I can't decide, send me one of each I'll do em both...