I also agree with ya'll. I think that a buck should get credit for every inch of antler that he has. I was just simply answering his question. He did not state if he wanted it scored B & C, P & Y, typical or non-typical. So, I was just answering his question from a typical stand point. As someone mentioned the deductions are taken away b/c of symtery.

I tell ya, I like this forum, but a lot you guys on here are quick to start an argument. It may be the built up frustration due to the long wait of season coming back in. If you read most threads in here, by the 3rd post, the whole tread is way out of text and the poster gets no answer to his or her question, all they get to read is an argument. JMO

STRUT I THINK YOUR RIGHT IN A WAY HOWEVER WHEN YOU GET A BUNCH OF GOOD OL'E BOYS DISCUSSING OPINIONS IT TENDS TO GET HEATED AT TIMES .... BUT I WOULD LIKE TO THINK ALL IN GOOD FUN .... AT LEAST IT IS FOR ME ;&gt)

ROLL TIDE
DD

HELL NO that aint no 150!!!

That 16ptr (I assume the right G1 is forked? Looks like it as is the left G1) is gonna go in the 160s in the gross score. No two ways about it!!!

That sucker stepped out in front of me and KAWHAM he's goin for a ride in the truck!
RA

yes, he scores over 150, easy.

He's a great trophy regardless of score. But i'm sure he will get a 10 for table fare.

BOY RECURVE YOU GOT THAT RIGHT BUDDY ...EMMM EMMMM

DD

I know I did not give much information about this deer. I know that he had 15 scorable points and was only 15 1/2 inches wide. He gross scored 158 and had a net score of 147 1/2. I am not sure but I think this is a typical net score. Not sure if he could even be classified as a non-typical.