I use a glove. I've never used a tab but I think I'll continue to use a glove.
EnglishHope

i don't find either comfortable at all , i do have a good calas on my middle fingure though!

I shoot 1 over 2 under

i always use a glove

Ive used the same tab for 7 years, trying a glove, an alaskan but no matter the glove it doesnt work for me yet

I use a tab. I just make 'em myself from $5 bags of scrap craft leather I get at Hobby lobby. Pretty easy to make since I shoot 3 under. The first one took a little while to get the right feel, but now, using that first as a template, it only takes about 10 minutes to cut one out with some EMS shears and a exacto knife for the hole. I always misplace them before I can wear them out, but I make 2 or 3 at a time and stash them. Been doing that for years, ever since I read Chuck Adams made his own that way.

I just picked up a glove made by vista and its basically a neet calf hair tab into a glove and I love it. I have the comfort of a glove and the clean release of a tab.

Haven't been shooting trad for long,(compound for years) but I made my own split finger tabs out of leather reminents and some hair on hide, and I love them.