I'd shoot the 10 pointer and use the antlers to tenderize the venison

It's funny you would even question that. 10 point!

I'd have to go with the 10. I'm not a trophy hunter but that doesn't mean I wouldn't like a nice trophy like that! If the spike was on his own and it was getting late he'd be a gonner too!!!!!!! YUM YUM!!!!!

I would take the ten too.

I might shoot both of them and then again I might not shoot either one of them. I would shoot the ten if hes mature and I would shoot the spike if he is over 1 1/2. If I want meat I'll just eat a doe, or thaw out a T-bone.

just shoot the naghbors chickens if your that hungry! j/k

First choice a doe, second the 10 pt. The spike I'll go back for in a year or two.