Ethical: Monster in doe season
#22
A few years back I shot a spike on the opening day of gun season. I dragged it to my truck and was sitting with a cup of coffee, enjoying the morning, when a piebald seven point ran down the hill and stopped 60 yards away. I did not have binoculars with me so I slid my .270 out of the case and watched the deer for several minutes through the scope. The rifle was unloaded and I never gave a thought to shooting since, at that time, the limit was one buck. I consider the chance at a buck that is 80% white a once in a lifetime opportunity but I have never regretted that I did not shoot. BTW another hunter did kill the deer and it was displayed as a full body mount at the county fair in the fall. Beautiful!
#23
Fork Horn
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 304
Likes: 0
From: Old Bridge, NJ
I personally know people who shoot more than the have the right too. I have seen the shoot 3 or 4 deer and just pile them up under their stands until nightfall.
I know another group of hunters who will shoot a doe, tag it, then butcher it up, and reuse the tag on another doe that they shoot later on or the next day.
I know another group of hunters who will shoot a doe, tag it, then butcher it up, and reuse the tag on another doe that they shoot later on or the next day.
#25
Thread Starter
Nontypical Buck
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 1,289
Likes: 0
From: Gypsum KS USA
Glad to see some other hunters on my side. My buddies are still giving me heck cuz I let a 14 pointer walk right by me on the first day of doe season, weird thing is is that he didn't have any girlies with him, just this monster buck.
#26
Nontypical Buck
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 4,966
Likes: 0
From: Harford Co Maryland USA
To me, it would be no different than shooting any deer out-of-season or at night. It's illegal, unethical and just plain wrong. I've used my buck tag early in years past and then had a much larger buck come stand broadside in easy bow range (most recently last year), but I had no choice except to pass. That's the chance you take when you decide to take a buck--there may be a bigger one nearby.
Today's small bucks are tomorrow's trophies.
Today's small bucks are tomorrow's trophies.
#27
Nomercy fortunantly in Va. this is not an issue, but if it was I would cry as I watched that big buck walk off into the distance. I for one am not willing to lose my truck and gun and then get to pay a big fine and possibly go to jail to boot. That and I am not one to break the law. (except speed limits)

The Tazman

The Tazman
#30
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 161
Likes: 0
From: Winthrop NY USA
If somebody wants horns that bad they can go find a fenced hunt somewhere. 10 acres with 25 trophy animals huddled against the fence. Perfectly legal and about as braggable as a buck out of season.


