Some nice bucks (pic)
02-23-2009 | 04:12 PM
#136
Banned
Joined: Sep 2008
Posts: 2,978
Likes: 0
From:
RE: Some nice bucks (pic)
"Tell Dad that Mathews bow with parallel limb design was not made before AR. I owna Mathews..Is there something you need to tell us. ? "
Yes. That pic is NOT pre-ar. And I never claimed it was.But it was the only one of thoseI postedthat isnt. Only reason I posted it was to show even though hes gettin' older, dad is still knockin' them down after showing some of his 60's -70's pics. That pic was last year. It also isnt a matthews. Its a diamond black ice. I dont think you can doubt the others....LOL. The 70's fashions are a bit unmistakable!(LOL) And the one pic I have from the 90's you can clearly see the old outdated long overdraw on my bow. (LOL)
Convincer livbucks? Convince of what? Only thing I was challenged on was that you said there were nothing but spikes and forkies and noone was killing deer in this area in the 70's, and they certainly werent as large as the GIANT (LOL) that rsb posted.. I think Ive more than proven that incorrect. The rest of my pics are just bonuses for you to look at. (LOL)
Thats but a few of our bucks..Btw, plenty of turkey,other coyotes and fox from calling. Trapping? Plenty of beaver, mink muskrat fox coon coyote pics...
The rediculous challenges and condescending attitudesget old when clowns have no idea who the hell they are talking to...Just because a man chooses to point out what liars pgc are and dont support the failed deer plan.
Yes. That pic is NOT pre-ar. And I never claimed it was.But it was the only one of thoseI postedthat isnt. Only reason I posted it was to show even though hes gettin' older, dad is still knockin' them down after showing some of his 60's -70's pics. That pic was last year. It also isnt a matthews. Its a diamond black ice. I dont think you can doubt the others....LOL. The 70's fashions are a bit unmistakable!(LOL) And the one pic I have from the 90's you can clearly see the old outdated long overdraw on my bow. (LOL)
Convincer livbucks? Convince of what? Only thing I was challenged on was that you said there were nothing but spikes and forkies and noone was killing deer in this area in the 70's, and they certainly werent as large as the GIANT (LOL) that rsb posted.. I think Ive more than proven that incorrect. The rest of my pics are just bonuses for you to look at. (LOL)
Thats but a few of our bucks..Btw, plenty of turkey,other coyotes and fox from calling. Trapping? Plenty of beaver, mink muskrat fox coon coyote pics...
The rediculous challenges and condescending attitudesget old when clowns have no idea who the hell they are talking to...Just because a man chooses to point out what liars pgc are and dont support the failed deer plan.
02-23-2009 | 05:06 PM
#138
Fork Horn
Joined: Sep 2008
Posts: 227
Likes: 0
RE: Some nice bucks (pic)
ORIGINAL: livbucks
Is that a pre-ar yote? Is that your convincer?
Is that a pre-ar yote? Is that your convincer?
02-23-2009 | 05:14 PM
#139
Typical Buck
Joined: Jul 2006
Posts: 584
Likes: 0
RE: Some nice bucks (pic)
ORIGINAL: bluebird2
Typical Whitetail Deer - Rifle (Page 1)
RANK NAME CITY COUNTY YEAR SCORE
1 JANOWSKY, FRITZ WELLSBURG, NY BRADFORD 1943 189-0
2 PARRY, IVAN GRAYSVILLE GREENE 1974 184-6
3 ALLISON, CHESTER HARLEYSVILLE BLAIR 1951 182-5
4 REIBSON, FLOYD FORKSVILLE SULLIVAN 1931 180-4
5 MILLER, RAYMOND E BEDFORD BEDFORD 1957 177-5
6 KINLEY, PERRY RIDGWAY JEFFERSON 1920 177-0
7 ZERBE, JOHN MCCLURE MIFFLIN 1936 176-5
8 RINEHULS, CLYDE H SAYRE BRADFORD 1944 176-0
9 YOUNG, ARTHUR CENTRE HALL MCKEAN 1930 175-4
10 HOFFMAN, ROBERT MT PLEASANT WESTMORELAND 1949 174-6
11 MCKANE, ROBERT QUAKERTOWN SULLIVAN 2004 174-4
12 BLACK, LEWIS DARLINGTON BEAVER 1979 174-1
13 KIFER, MEAD CLARION CLARION 1947 173-3
14 LABROSSE JR, RONALD J MCMURRAY WASHINGTON 1996 172-6
15 DUNN, CRAIG SMETHPORT MCKEAN 1930 172-4
16 SCHUCKERS, WALTER REYNOLDSVILLE JEFFERSON 2006 171-4
17 WALKER, PAUL SOMERSET SOMERSET 1941 171-2
18 HELANDER, HARRY REW MCKEAN 1955 170-4
18 BOLTON, TYLER WERNERSVILLE BERKS 2006 170-4
18 BURTON, RALPH E CYCLONE MCKEAN 1933 170-4
21 FEATHERS, CLAUDE E FREEDOM BLAIR 1943 170-0
22 PAINTER, LYSLE R NEW WILMINGTON JEFFERSON 1954 169-6
22 SQUIRES, RALPH W MONTROSE SUSQUEHANNA 1941 169-6
24 ROTHROCK, GEORGE PHILIPSBURG CENTRE 1931 169-2
25 BOWSER, WAYNE MARKLEYSBURG FAYETTE 1977 169-1
26 FEHLINGER, CHARLES DALLAS LUZERNE 1945 169-0
26 SCHULTZ, EZRA NEW ALBANY BRADFORD 1927 169-0
28 SUTLEY, E G WEST HICKORY FOREST 1932 168-7
28 MILLER, WINFIELD ELVERSON CHESTER 1945 168-7
28 SHINE, CHARLES JAMESTOWN MERCER 1942 168-7
31 SWEENEY, PAUL LILLY INDIANA 1955 168-6
32 CORNMAN, RONALD CARLISLE CUMBERLAND UNKN 168-5
33 SHAFFER, ROBERT EDINBORO MERCER 1956 168-3
34 NAU, BERNARD MONROVILLE WESTMORELAND 1958 167-4
35 DAVIS, DEBORAH LIGONIER WASHINGTON 1989 167-2
36 REDCAY, BRIAN ELIZABETHTOWN DAUPHIN 1984 167-1
37 WALCHESKI, VINCE CANTON BRADFORD 1932 166-7
38 BURLINGAME, CHARLES COOPERSTOWN CRAWFORD 1946 166-5
38 HOUSEKNECHT, BRADY HUGHESVILLE LYCOMING 1940 166-5
40 DE DIONISIO, RICK ERIE ERIE 1985 166-4
What do you think of those pre-AR dinks.
Typical Whitetail Deer - Rifle (Page 1)
RANK NAME CITY COUNTY YEAR SCORE
1 JANOWSKY, FRITZ WELLSBURG, NY BRADFORD 1943 189-0
2 PARRY, IVAN GRAYSVILLE GREENE 1974 184-6
3 ALLISON, CHESTER HARLEYSVILLE BLAIR 1951 182-5
4 REIBSON, FLOYD FORKSVILLE SULLIVAN 1931 180-4
5 MILLER, RAYMOND E BEDFORD BEDFORD 1957 177-5
6 KINLEY, PERRY RIDGWAY JEFFERSON 1920 177-0
7 ZERBE, JOHN MCCLURE MIFFLIN 1936 176-5
8 RINEHULS, CLYDE H SAYRE BRADFORD 1944 176-0
9 YOUNG, ARTHUR CENTRE HALL MCKEAN 1930 175-4
10 HOFFMAN, ROBERT MT PLEASANT WESTMORELAND 1949 174-6
11 MCKANE, ROBERT QUAKERTOWN SULLIVAN 2004 174-4
12 BLACK, LEWIS DARLINGTON BEAVER 1979 174-1
13 KIFER, MEAD CLARION CLARION 1947 173-3
14 LABROSSE JR, RONALD J MCMURRAY WASHINGTON 1996 172-6
15 DUNN, CRAIG SMETHPORT MCKEAN 1930 172-4
16 SCHUCKERS, WALTER REYNOLDSVILLE JEFFERSON 2006 171-4
17 WALKER, PAUL SOMERSET SOMERSET 1941 171-2
18 HELANDER, HARRY REW MCKEAN 1955 170-4
18 BOLTON, TYLER WERNERSVILLE BERKS 2006 170-4
18 BURTON, RALPH E CYCLONE MCKEAN 1933 170-4
21 FEATHERS, CLAUDE E FREEDOM BLAIR 1943 170-0
22 PAINTER, LYSLE R NEW WILMINGTON JEFFERSON 1954 169-6
22 SQUIRES, RALPH W MONTROSE SUSQUEHANNA 1941 169-6
24 ROTHROCK, GEORGE PHILIPSBURG CENTRE 1931 169-2
25 BOWSER, WAYNE MARKLEYSBURG FAYETTE 1977 169-1
26 FEHLINGER, CHARLES DALLAS LUZERNE 1945 169-0
26 SCHULTZ, EZRA NEW ALBANY BRADFORD 1927 169-0
28 SUTLEY, E G WEST HICKORY FOREST 1932 168-7
28 MILLER, WINFIELD ELVERSON CHESTER 1945 168-7
28 SHINE, CHARLES JAMESTOWN MERCER 1942 168-7
31 SWEENEY, PAUL LILLY INDIANA 1955 168-6
32 CORNMAN, RONALD CARLISLE CUMBERLAND UNKN 168-5
33 SHAFFER, ROBERT EDINBORO MERCER 1956 168-3
34 NAU, BERNARD MONROVILLE WESTMORELAND 1958 167-4
35 DAVIS, DEBORAH LIGONIER WASHINGTON 1989 167-2
36 REDCAY, BRIAN ELIZABETHTOWN DAUPHIN 1984 167-1
37 WALCHESKI, VINCE CANTON BRADFORD 1932 166-7
38 BURLINGAME, CHARLES COOPERSTOWN CRAWFORD 1946 166-5
38 HOUSEKNECHT, BRADY HUGHESVILLE LYCOMING 1940 166-5
40 DE DIONISIO, RICK ERIE ERIE 1985 166-4
What do you think of those pre-AR dinks.
I don’t know what point you were trying to make by posting those best rifle harvest buck scores but you probably missed your target.
I have take the liberty of breaking them down to time periods and then averaged the number of inches per buck for each time period. Here is the data for the 39 bucks that had a known year of harvest.
Time period………………….number of entries……………………..average inches of antler
Prior to 1931.……………………….4.…………… ………………...........173.2
1931-1940.………………………….7.………… …………………...........177.3
1941-1950.…………………………12.………… …………………..........172.6
1951-1960.………………………….6.………… …………………...........172.2
1961-1970.………………………….0.………… ………………….............N/A
1971-1980.………………………….3.………… …………………...........176.0
1981-1990.………………………….3.………… …………………...........167.0
1991-2000.………………………….1.………… …………………...........172.6
2001-present………………………..3.………… …………………............172.2
All of the ones since 2001 were harvested after antler restrictions. How many more do you think will be entered in that since 2001 column over the next few years?
R.S. Bodenhorn
02-23-2009 | 05:33 PM
#140
Nontypical Buck
Joined: Apr 2008
Posts: 3,879
Likes: 0
RE: Some nice bucks (pic)
Thank you very much for proving ARs did not increase the rack sizes of 2.5+ buck as BTB and Livbucks claimed. You are without a doubt my best buddy when it comes to proving ARs have failed to produce the predicted results. Good job RSB, I couldn't have done it any better myself!!