Paul L Mohr

I have a suggestion, if you are worried about getting eaten by a large bear stay out of it's back yard and don't shoot at it. I don't care what kind of gun you have it does not garauntee a one shot stop. Shooting large dangerous game is... well, dangerous.

I never get this argument when there are people that kill large dangerous game with slug guns, muzzle loaders and bows. I mean I guess if you want to shoot it from 500 yards away, hit it in the foot and have it drop dead than an ultra high powered rifle might be in the cards. But don't sit there and tell us that you HAVE to have that big of a rifle to kill game like that. There have been plenty of animals like that taken cleanly with a 30-06 and lesser cartridges.

My opinion anyway, but then again I don't hunt bear, for the reason stated above. I don't feel like getting eaten by one. Same reason I don't swim in the ocean. I have a pact with sharks, they stay out of my back yard and I'll stay out of theirs.

Paul

ipscshooter

I think you're missing the point that the .300 RUM is not a "lower powered rifle."

By the way... watched the youtube video. That must have been pretty exciting...

But, they don't say what cartridge either of those guys was using. For all we know... coulda been a .243.

Frank in the Laurels

Just use great bullets...X-bullets, partitions etc..do not attempt this with off the shelf factory loaded junk bullets..the jackets are to thin...REMEMBER your on the menu when hunting these beasts.....shoot straight and practice on cardboard cutouts..should have been doing this all summer, but better late than never..GOOD LUCK and know where the kill area is from all angles....send the guide first into the alders to retrieve and make sure your faster than the camera man... more than enough energy. lots have been killed by 30/30's a few riflemen have been eaten also....

Pioneer2

I had a 14 day hunt in the Yukon in 1994 and it turned out my"guide" had never set foot in the Yukon until shortly before I showed up.Hired him sight unseen to cover the number of hunters.He was scared of his ass of bears and was fired for cowardice in a bear situation 2 weeks later.I shot a 15.5 year old sow and he was none too crazy about stalking it so I left him 1/2 way down the mountain as I didn't come that far to watch wildlife at a safe distance.He had a German hunter with him and a big boar walked out at less than 25 yards and the guide just about soiled himself and forbade the hunter to shoot.He's lucky he wasn't butstroked...........When he got back to camp and the German talked to the owner he was fired on the spot............Harold

robbcayman

Acutally that was a 22 cartridge j/k Agree to disagree, but I honestly have the guys best interest at heart. No matter what hunt safe and have fun.

DM

No problem, i'd just like to see you back up your "best interest" with some facts... (read proof)

DM

bd chambers

I think a 300 weatherby mag w/np will do the job. There is a 220 grain round nose for heavy bone stuff. I would think a 300 rum would be more than enough, shot placement is the key.

robbcayman

Sure, a larger cartridge leaves a larger hole there is your proof. This is not to say you need a cannon, but I would go with someone who is a professional i.e. a guide over your "message board" advice.

ipscshooter

Don't laugh... it's possible. There's a picture of a lady at the site below, who killed a huge grizzly in self defense using a .22 (her story is about 1/8th down the page).

http://www.brassmonkeyproductions.com/grizzly/Part3.html

ipscshooter

I'm not sure that a 3/100ths" larger hole is significant. The concern is, and I think should be, penetration, as the "size of hole" difference between a .308 caliber bullet and a .338 caliber bullet is pretty miniscule. Thus, the question becomes whether a 200 gr. "premium-type" bullet out of the .300 RUM hitting with 3800 ft. lbs. of energy will penetrate as well as a 220 gr. or 250 gr. "premium-type" bullet out of a .338 WMhitting with 3500 ft. lbs. of energy. What is their relative propensity to break through bone?

Keep in mind that in that youtube video, those guys were, originally, BOWHUNTING for grizzlies, and only decided to use the rifles based on weather. I can't believe that there might be guides out there who would say, "I'll take you bowhunting for bears, but, if you want to use a rifle, leave your .300 RUM at home because I won't hunt with you unless you're using at least a .338 WM."