If you had to choose, i know you all have your diff opinions and may hate them both but the are the two im debating on with myself. highest % is probably what ill use. Dont look at it as fixed Vs. mechanical look at it as which will perform better...

cant really say without knowing your setup. but its hard to beat a muzzy.

07 element
65lbs.
27.5" GT expedition 5575 2" blazers
hunting white tail

Id go with Rage. Killer design and killer results.

I'd personally go with the muzzy's with that setup.

can never go wrong with muzzy's, they are 2 for 2 in my book, I just restocked and bought the MX-3's. I bought a set of retractables and they just don't fly right out of my bow.

Muzzy's .... Period.

I couldn't pick one I need a fixed for my blind. If I was in a tree I would want the rage for quicker kills.

I have not shot either but from what I have read on HNI and other forums you cannot go wrong with either.
Rage seems to be the hot one though right now. Good Luck this coming season.