Barrel proofing, How?
#21
Well, as you no doubt know, the DGW catalog has proof-load tables in the back, which show whatthe proof load for various gauges was back in the 19th century -if I recall correctly, these are British proof loads (and perhaps some Belgian). But again, it doesn't describe what to look for AFTER the load is fired!
Another problem is that our powders today are different from those used when those proof tables were developed. And who know how much different!
Another problem is that our powders today are different from those used when those proof tables were developed. And who know how much different!
#22
Thread Starter
Nontypical Buck
Joined: Aug 2005
Posts: 1,081
Likes: 0
From: New Mexico
Well I've been in communication with the Birmingham Proof House as well as a gunsmith friend and here is some of the preliminary info. I'm still waiting on some clarification from BPH, they have a whole manual of specs based on gun type etc. I'm trying to get the specifics for black powder guns.
The gunsmith friend suggests that there should be no change in dimentions in the area of and nearthe chamber. He also noted that a change of 1 or 2 thousanths probably would still be safe but would prefer no change. He also said that the nipple would most likely blow out before the barrel would bulge, at least that's what he has seen when people have brought in guns that were over loaded or shot with smokeless loads. In his experience, a barrel is much more likely to fail from short starting the projectile than from overcharging the barrel. This of course is not an endorsment to overload a barrel, always follow the manufacturers load recomendations.
Still waiting on other sources of infomation and will post it when it arrives.
Have a good day.
The gunsmith friend suggests that there should be no change in dimentions in the area of and nearthe chamber. He also noted that a change of 1 or 2 thousanths probably would still be safe but would prefer no change. He also said that the nipple would most likely blow out before the barrel would bulge, at least that's what he has seen when people have brought in guns that were over loaded or shot with smokeless loads. In his experience, a barrel is much more likely to fail from short starting the projectile than from overcharging the barrel. This of course is not an endorsment to overload a barrel, always follow the manufacturers load recomendations.
Still waiting on other sources of infomation and will post it when it arrives.
Have a good day.
#23
Thanks for the information, Dave. BTW, where do you live in N.M.? I have lived in both Alb. and Las Vegas, and my brother still lives in Alb.
Great place to live & hunt!!
Larry
Great place to live & hunt!!
Larry




