Who is a REAL hunter?
#51
#53
Now when it comes to tuna fishing, I won't argue his skills.
#54
Nontypical Buck
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 2,164
Likes: 0
From: Moravia NY USA
I have also seen him hunt some kind of goose in Texas with his longbow, that takes skill.
#55
I understand the allure of Tred Barta because he hunts the old fashioned way, but he still hunts with outfitters just like all the rest of the "Pro Hunters" mentioned. Every single show he does he has someone guiding him to his animal and most of the time he scares it away before he gets a change to take a shot. And then if he does actually take a shot, he misses the majority of the time. I've seen him make more bad shots on animals than any other person on TV. I think it's a little unfair to classify him as a real hunter simply because he uses a stick & string with stone-tipped wooden arrows. Anyone can pick that gear up but it doesn't mean they're a real hunter.
And I know he's having medical issues but that doesn't mean I can't call it like I see it.
And I know he's having medical issues but that doesn't mean I can't call it like I see it.
Last edited by early in; 12-25-2009 at 06:40 PM.
#58
I agree with everyone that the shows are often on game farms over food plots with deer that stand still for five minutes while the hunter readies him/herself. I can't think of ever seeing a deer in Minnesota stand still close to that long to get a shot. That being said though, I like Roger Raglin because of how excited he gets with every deer...and I like Jim Shockey...say what you want...the guy hunts big game everywhere...is a good shot, hunts hard, GUIDES people successully....in thousands of acres of wild land many will never set foot on...as far as tv guys go, he is probably the best...I also like Greg Miller...as I think he has hunted his share of big woods whitetails..maybe not so much anymore...but these guys could get the job done.
#60
I have to agree on Jim Shockey. Especially since he does guide people.
Very interesting comments so far.
What are your thoughts on "The Bucks of Tecomate" show? I was reading about how they grow them that big and it sounded like they fenced it in. The El Cazador(?) ranch or whatever it is. They sure grow some monsters in any case.
The leased land we hunt has been like heaven after hunting public land for most of my life. I've had 2-3 nice bucks come out together and seen some "Tecomate" size bucks but couldn't get a shot. We had one on the land this year at least 24" inside spread and huge rack. No one got a chance at him but was seen by the neighbor on our side of the small stream so he was there somewhere. The neighbors and ourselves pass up small bucks and when the doe population is down (like now) pass up does also. The area being hunted definitely can make someone more successful. Here's a pic of the buck that was taken right in front of my stand the year before I got in on the lease (four years ago). The first two years I got a 9 point (17" spread on both) buck off the land each year. And the last two years I've been passing them that size and smaller wanting a chance at some of the big guys roaming the land. In all my years I've never before passed on a buck when hunting public land.
Very interesting comments so far.
What are your thoughts on "The Bucks of Tecomate" show? I was reading about how they grow them that big and it sounded like they fenced it in. The El Cazador(?) ranch or whatever it is. They sure grow some monsters in any case.
The leased land we hunt has been like heaven after hunting public land for most of my life. I've had 2-3 nice bucks come out together and seen some "Tecomate" size bucks but couldn't get a shot. We had one on the land this year at least 24" inside spread and huge rack. No one got a chance at him but was seen by the neighbor on our side of the small stream so he was there somewhere. The neighbors and ourselves pass up small bucks and when the doe population is down (like now) pass up does also. The area being hunted definitely can make someone more successful. Here's a pic of the buck that was taken right in front of my stand the year before I got in on the lease (four years ago). The first two years I got a 9 point (17" spread on both) buck off the land each year. And the last two years I've been passing them that size and smaller wanting a chance at some of the big guys roaming the land. In all my years I've never before passed on a buck when hunting public land.
Last edited by warbirdlover; 12-25-2009 at 08:26 PM.


