I'm going after ducks this weekend and I can't decide which 12 gauge to use. My mossy pump can hold three 3" shells but it jangles like a washing machine. I also have a two year old Franchi o/u which shoots sweet as silk. To make things worse, the Mossy pump is much better at taking abuse and I can replace it for about the price of a pair of boots. Both guns kick so that part is not really a factor.

Sometimes I need that third shot to hit what I'm after. Which would you suggest me taking into the blind?

I`d go with the pump personally. I like the option of that third shot also.

Ron

I'd go with the pump. You'll be wishin you had that third shot.

Pump for me...I definitely need the third shot. Plus the whole thing about replacing them. I would never takea nice gun duck hunting.

Take the pump. Rattling is not really an issue. Don't take that Franchi and drop it in the mud or water...

I would take which ever I could shoot the best.If there isn't much difference, I'd take a pump.

I prefer to hear three bangs before the cussing starts.