I'm going after ducks this weekend and I can't decide which 12 gauge to use. My mossy pump can hold three 3" shells but it jangles like a washing machine. I also have a two year old Franchi o/u which shoots sweet as silk. To make things worse, the Mossy pump is much better at taking abuse and I can replace it for about the price of a pair of boots. Both guns kick so that part is not really a factor.

Sometimes I need that third shot to hit what I'm after. Which would you suggest me taking into the blind?