well im useing my black hawk short hornet with XX75 arrows and i have thunder heads and crimson talon XT's which would be a better for deer?
i know its really up to me but i just want yalls opion

IMO, I would not use either with your setup. I'd first rather use a two bladed COC head, or heads such as Wensels, Snuffers, etc.

Crimson Talon heads SUCK - they do, look at them !

Thunderheads are time tested, tough and ultra sharp

What Bob said.

I seem to always come back to magnus. Cheap, and good.

yeah yeah then how do you explain the doe in my freezer that had a hole in her that was better than the holes my uncles .257 roberts left in his deer?
nothing against the thunder heads what you said about them is verry true!!!

I had great results with the Snuffers out of my 50# Longbow, complete pass thru on a buck this year, he went 20 yards and piled up! Didn't get a chance to send a Woodsman head thru one because I MISSED!!!!!!!!!!!!![8D]