Community
Technical Find or ask for all the information on setting up, tuning, and shooting your bow. If it's the technical side of archery, you'll find it here.

Bow Choice? Give me your opinion...

Thread Tools
 
Old 11-29-2004 | 05:38 PM
  #11  
Nontypical Buck
 
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 1,398
Likes: 0
From: Eastern PA USA
Default RE: Bow Choice? Give me your opinion...

I would also suggest you give the Darton Tundra Extreme a look, but I'm not sure if they come in 80# though. I've owned a lot of bows in the last few years, including one mentioned as "best" earlier in this thread. I wouldn't trade the Tundra for any 2 of them!
JOE PA is offline  
Reply
Old 11-29-2004 | 05:55 PM
  #12  
 
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 316
Likes: 0
From: Kansas
Default RE: Bow Choice? Give me your opinion...

I would also ask why you want an 80# bow. Drop that to 70#'s and with your draw length, you will still be smokin arrows. The lighter draw will also help "control" the bow better. There will be less strain, allowing you to think about form and execution more. Other than that, I can not add to what has already been stated. Maybe get a coach if you continue to see those creeping shots days.
JMAC
jmac_or is offline  
Reply
Old 11-29-2004 | 11:22 PM
  #13  
Thread Starter
 
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 27
Likes: 0
Default RE: Bow Choice? Give me your opinion...

ORIGINAL: Straightarrow

1.) Consistant accuracy!
2.) Reliability (I don't want to worry about cam, string, or cable problems where the bow always has to be readjusted or meticulously checked)
3.) Forgivness
4.) Quietness
Almost every bow made is equally accurate. Consistency comes from the archer form and his ability to tune the bow.

The reliability you're referring to, comes from the quality of the string. I highly recommend getting a custom made string to eliminate any concern in this area. Most stock strings are adequate at best. Since you should regularly replace your string, it's my opinion that you should start out with what you'll always be shooting. There are many guys making reasonably priced custom strings that will not creep and will not stretch after a very short break-in period.

Forgiveness - It sounds like the bow you're currently shooting is designed on the more forgiving side than the ones you're considering.

Quiet - Almost alll new bows are quiet - even the very inexpensive ones. If they aren't, a few cheap add-on silencing products will quickly make it so. I personally would not choose a bow based on this requirement. It's simply too easy to get almost all current bows to shoot very quietly.

As a side note, I think a guy with your draw length should stay will the longer ATA bows. An 8" or longer brace (distance from deepest part of grip to the string) will also add some forgiveness. A reflex bow has the limbs attached in front of the bow's grip. A deflex riser would have the limbs attached in the rear of the grip - towards the archer.
Can you give me a couple resources for custom-made strings? Maybe a website or a member of this forum or another... Are the custom strings just coated in a non-stretching material or are they actually created from an entirely unique material?
slim9300 is offline  
Reply
Old 11-29-2004 | 11:40 PM
  #14  
Thread Starter
 
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 27
Likes: 0
Default RE: Bow Choice? Give me your opinion...

ORIGINAL: Arthur P

I've got a 33.5" draw length and shoot fingers and, when I shoot a compound, it's a ProTec with an axle to axle length of 46" and 8" brace height. I've got LXPro limbs on mine, but Hoyt has discontinued them and replaced them with XT4000 limbs this year. (Looks like the same limb but with a different name?) I'd suggest the ProTec with Cam 1/2 and XT4000 limbs. It is available up to 80 pounds draw weight. Unless you just want to switch to release shooting[:'(], this is the bow that best fits your requirements.

I had a Pearson a few years back and had the same problem with wandering windage. I tracked the problem down to the grip. For some reason, I couldn't grab the handle the same way, from one day to the next, and the bow was extremely 'torque-y'. So, I replaced that tacky, soft rubber grip with their optional wood grip. The bow was still very particular about how it wanted to be gripped, but it was much easier to get it consistent from one day to the next.

Also, it sounds like you need to get your string and cable twisted up some to get your draw weight back.

I think a guy with your draw length should stay will the longer ATA bows. An 8" or longer brace (distance from deepest part of grip to the string) will also add some forgiveness.
Straightarrow is right on the money, IMO. The longer an arrow stays on the string, the longer you've got to screw up the shot. With my 33.5" draw and 8" brace height, my arrow travels with the string for 25.5" before it's free. If I had a bow with a 6.5" brace, it'd be on the string for 27". That's another inch-and-a-half of travel time. Another 1.5" for me to move my bow arm. Another 1/5" for the bow's torque to mess with my arrow flight. Another 1.5" where the string can interfere with the arrow's paradox.

As far as speed goes, the longer the arrow is powered by the string the faster it goes, BUT! How much power stroke do you need, anyway? Somebody with a 30" draw and a bow with a 6.5" brace height winds up with a power stroke of 23.5". If you've got a 32" draw and use a bow with an 8" brace, you've got a power stroke of 24". You've still got the other guy beat and are using a more forgiving brace height.

The big thing about reflex vs deflex risers is torque. With a reflex riser, the bow's grip is between your string hand and the limb butts. Your bow hand has enough mechanical advantage to really twist the snot out of the grip, especially on a high letoff bow. The deflex riser puts the limb butts between the grip and the string hand, eliminating the bow hand's mechanical advantage. Deflex risers are very resistant to torque and are much more stable and 'forgiving' as a result.

Reflex risers are for short armed little twerps who want more arrow speed and are willing to deal with all the torque problems of a reflex riser to get a low brace height and longer power stroke. Ape armed guys -like us- can get the benefits of a high brace height AND deflex riser and still get more power stroke than the stubbies can. [8D]
So do you believe that shooting with fingers is as accurate and consistant as shooting with a release?

Also, my Pearson bow has the wood grip not the plastic one. I have pretty large hands but the grip seems pretty thick to me. I never thought about how the grip affects the shot and accuracy.

So do you perfer the Hoyt ProTec better then the Pearson? What are the advantages to the Hoyt?

Finally, it may seem kind of trivial, but what kind of groups do you shoot with the Hoyt and what is the longest distance you can confidently shoot? Also, what draw weight do you shoot on your ProTec?

Here is a pic of my bow:

Thanks for your help.

Conlan
slim9300 is offline  
Reply
Old 11-29-2004 | 11:59 PM
  #15  
Thread Starter
 
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 27
Likes: 0
Default RE: Bow Choice? Give me your opinion...

ORIGINAL: jmac_or

I would also ask why you want an 80# bow. Drop that to 70#'s and with your draw length, you will still be smokin arrows. The lighter draw will also help "control" the bow better. There will be less strain, allowing you to think about form and execution more. Other than that, I can not add to what has already been stated. Maybe get a coach if you continue to see those creeping shots days.
JMAC
Not to act like a tuff-guy or anything, but pulling back an 80lbs.+ draw weight is very easy. On many occasions I shoot 100+ arrows during practice and I don't experience any strain. Not to mention, any new bow I would buy would have a 75-80% let-off. On a side note, my dad used to shoot his PSE compound wheel bow at 90 something lbs. with a let-off of basically nothing. But all this talk is pointless, I will shoot what I feel comfortable with and I appreciate your advice.
slim9300 is offline  
Reply
Old 11-30-2004 | 12:00 AM
  #16  
Thread Starter
 
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 27
Likes: 0
Default RE: Bow Choice? Give me your opinion...

ORIGINAL: JOE PA

I would also suggest you give the Darton Tundra Extreme a look, but I'm not sure if they come in 80# though. I've owned a lot of bows in the last few years, including one mentioned as "best" earlier in this thread. I wouldn't trade the Tundra for any 2 of them!
What is the ATA length of the Darton Tundra Extreme? Brace height?
slim9300 is offline  
Reply
Old 11-30-2004 | 04:57 AM
  #17  
 
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 2,413
Likes: 0
From:
Default RE: Bow Choice? Give me your opinion...

Can you give me a couple resources for custom-made strings?
There's probably a couple who frequent this forum. If not, you can go to the forum in the following link, which has many advertising and several who post a lot. [link]http://www.archerytalk.com/vb/[/link]

Custom strings are better, because of the methods used to tie the string, pre-stretch it, and serve it correctly and carefully. The string materials used are the same. However, there are quite a few choices on the market, and I'm partial to Brownell's Ultracam, which has the least stretch of any.

Speaking of forgiving bows, Reflex makes a long ATA bow that has some good specs. I can't remember the model name, but Chuck Adams shoots it.
Straightarrow is offline  
Reply
Old 11-30-2004 | 05:55 AM
  #18  
Nontypical Buck
 
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 1,398
Likes: 0
From: Eastern PA USA
Default RE: Bow Choice? Give me your opinion...

One thing I would definitely change on your setup is the bow quiver. You can get a better quiver that keeps the arrows closer to the bow for much reduced torque. You could also take the wood side plates off your Pearson, and cover the riser with fleece or moleskin and see if that doesn't improve your possible torque issues. I personally would not expect great accuracy with the Whisker Biscuit shooting fingers, but I guess it can be done. I know that guys do quite well with them shooting with a release aid.

The Darton Tundra Extreme is 40.5 Axle to Axle with a 7.5" brace height. It is rated @ 311 IBO, so it is very fast for such forgiving specs. My old damaged shoulders are pulling #61 and the bow is putting out 65 lb./ft. of kinetic energy (29.5" draw).

Darton Archery

The Reflex model that Straightarrow is referring to is the Reflex Caribou. I think it is about 42 or 44" ATA and has a brace of 9" or so. It is not a fast bow, but should be forgiving.
JOE PA is offline  
Reply
Old 11-30-2004 | 07:11 AM
  #19  
Giant Nontypical
 
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 9,175
Likes: 0
Default RE: Bow Choice? Give me your opinion...

So do you believe that shooting with fingers is as accurate and consistant as shooting with a release?
It depends on the person and on the application. For most people who have a goal of pinwheeling 1" dia X-rings, shot after shot, probably not. For hunting, where you're shooting to hit a soccerball size kill area, fingers release is definitely as accurate and consistent. Assuming, of course, you have a bow that is long enough to allow a fingers release and you've done your part with practicing and developing an accurate, consistent release.

Plus, fingers release has several advantages over mechanical releases. Primarily, you don't get that metallic, game spooking 'CLICK' at the release. If you forget your tab/glove and don't have a backup in your pocket, you can still shoot barefingered. If you forget your release and don't have a backup, you go back home. You can buy a whole pocketful of tabs for what one decent release will cost, and similar gloves/tabs will give you a similar release. You just have to hope a backup release will shoot close to the same as your primary release. Often they don't.

And you don't have to worry about clanking your fingers against the bow or the stand and scaring all the critters out of the county. A release, swinging on a wrist strap tho....

For myself, I actually do shoot better with my fingers than I can with a release. I guess it's one of those 'old dog, new tricks' thingies.

So do you perfer the Hoyt ProTec better then the Pearson? What are the advantages to the Hoyt?
Other than the Hoyt split limbs being far superior to Pearson's - wider and more stable with better construction - and better performance from Hoyt's Cam 1/2 than you can get with Pearson's single cam system - I have never had any problem getting a consistent, repeatable grip with Hoyt handles.

How far can I confidently shoot? If you're talking targets, I'll shot with confidence out to 80 yards and beyond, barebow and fingers release. If you're talking game animals, I have a personal limit no further than 30 yards. If I can't get within 30 yards of the animal I want, I have not earned the right to draw my bow. That is simply my challenge to myself and has no bearing on my shooting skill. I bowhunt to get close to animals. If I were taking 50 yard shots, I figure I might as well be using a 30-30.

As to what size groups I currently shoot with my Hoyt, honestly... I suck. My shoulder is shot, from shooting ultra heavy draw bows in my younger days, when they were easy to handle. 15 years ago, I was shooting compounds up to 100 pounds and longbows up to 120 pounds. Now I've got arthritis in the shoulder joint and a collarbone that pops out of socket at my sternum. Before the shoulder went south on me though, I could hold archer's minute of angle or better out to 90 meters. When I first got it, my Hoyt was set at 60. Now I've had to back off to 50 and it's gotten to where I can't handle even that any more. It looks like if I want to continue shooting archery, I'm gonna have to switch to lefty.

That's my only comment on your preference for shooting 80 pounds.
Arthur P is offline  
Reply
Old 11-30-2004 | 07:51 AM
  #20  
Nontypical Buck
 
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 2,994
Likes: 0
From:
Default RE: Bow Choice? Give me your opinion...

Slim, from your pic above, it looks like you have one of your vanes lined up to go right through the black part of the WB. Perhaps not since you shoot fingers, but the fact that it's more "wavy" and distorted than the other two suggests you are getting hard contact.

You may want to rotate your nocks so that the vanes clear the black fibers and see if you get better arrow flight. Of course this will most likely necessitate a retune and sight in, so keep that in mind...
Rangeball is offline  
Reply


Contact Us - Archive - Advertising - Cookie Policy - Privacy Statement - Terms of Service -

Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.