RE: Does This Sound Familiar
 

You didn't venture a guess so you don't get an answer just yet. I just posted the point , but you may have been making your post at the same time.

RE: Does This Sound Familiar
 

ok i see point my guess was 28 and 30 but you said btb wasnt close so iguess i play your game
and wait a week or sothen come back and see if you gave out the answer

RE: Does This Sound Familiar
 

Oh yeah, decisions and policies utilizedbefore 1980 are something that would really fit now.

Lets see before 1980....

Jimmy Carter was elected[:'(]

We waited in lines 20 deep for 3 bucks worth of gas[:'(]

We helped put Sadam Hussein and Bin Laden in power[:'(]

We ran out of Vietnam after grinding up 50,000 brave young men for nothing[:'(]

Oh and wehad a deer management style that put a maximum sustained body count as theonly realgoal[:'(]

RE: Does This Sound Familiar
 

Did you even bother to read the quote? Did you note they were using the same basic criteria that the PGC is using today?

RE: Does This Sound Familiar
 

I read all the quotes including this one

Which is what the response was directed toward. We all know that there has been a shift from one of Maximum sustained yeild to an RDD optimal sustained yeild. The terminology to justify both is similar but they are very different management styles

RE: Does This Sound Familiar
 

I doubt that even 1% of the hunters know that change has occurred and I doubt that 10% of those on this MB know what the RRD optimal sustained yield is based on. But, the fact remains that the change was based on the political pressure exerted by DCNR and the timber industry and it is totally subjective and not in the best interest of hunters or the deer herd.

RE: Does This Sound Familiar
 

I'm not surprised that you minimize the ability of PA's hunters and the members of this board to understand deer management given that you thinkDr James Kroll doen't even understand it.

RE: Does This Sound Familiar
 

Here is an example of why I said that. RDD is not the optimal sustainable yield as you claimed. RDD standards for the relative deer density, not the optimal sustainable yield.

RE: Does This Sound Familiar
 

I think it has something to do with a 5 % drop in breathing rates,and that is directly tied to the failed attempts in the past to educate PA hunters about how little we really know about breathing and its affects on our habitat,stable and constant breathing is a goal we should all strive for,not just for ourselves but for future breathers as well.[&:]

RE: Does This Sound Familiar
 

BB doesnt understand that the breathing rate samples shifted in emphasisto the Marcellus shale shelffrom the non marcellus areas so the drop in breathing rates is really not a drop because the gasses away from the Marcellus are easier to breathe so the breathing rates most likely actually increased:D