Semi autos in PA.
#11
Fork Horn
Joined: Dec 2008
Posts: 143
Likes: 0
From: Washington County
ORIGINAL: sammy_tat
So people who use clubs or drowned their catch or choke an animal are in use of illegal dispatch weapons and ways?
So people who use clubs or drowned their catch or choke an animal are in use of illegal dispatch weapons and ways?
#13
Thread Starter
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 179
Likes: 0
Again,once an animal iscaught in a trap,the hunt is over.Onlything left to do is dispatch the animal. I will continue to dispatch the ways I do. If an encounter ever comes when a semi is in my hand and I what I am doing is wrong, then yes I will take it to court. To go out of my way just to do it in front of a WCO or PGC is not my way of doing things even though it sounds like a taunt from you. Maybe one of these days you all might be in my presence when this happens. But I am not going out of my way to do it. Hunting and trapping not the same. If it was,then once again, clubs,choking, drowning would be illegal also.
Starting to wonder who are the ones against or 2nd ammendment rights? Makes hunters wonders I bet. 2nd ammendment and hunting goes hand and hand.
Starting to wonder who are the ones against or 2nd ammendment rights? Makes hunters wonders I bet. 2nd ammendment and hunting goes hand and hand.
#14
The WCO won't have to see you do it. Simply coming out of the woods with the semi and an animal thats been shot ought to be enough.
Why would you even put yourself in that position?
Why would you even put yourself in that position?
#15
Fork Horn
Joined: Dec 2008
Posts: 143
Likes: 0
From: Washington County
ORIGINAL: sammy_tat
Again,once an animal iscaught in a trap,the hunt is over.Onlything left to do is dispatch the animal. I will continue to dispatch the ways I do. If an encounter ever comes when a semi is in my hand and I what I am doing is wrong, then yes I will take it to court. To go out of my way just to do it in front of a WCO or PGC is not my way of doing things even though it sounds like a taunt from you. Maybe one of these days you all might be in my presence when this happens. But I am not going out of my way to do it. Hunting and trapping not the same. If it was,then once again, clubs,choking, drowning would be illegal also.
Starting to wonder who are the ones against or 2nd ammendment rights? Makes hunters wonders I bet. 2nd ammendment and hunting goes hand and hand.
Again,once an animal iscaught in a trap,the hunt is over.Onlything left to do is dispatch the animal. I will continue to dispatch the ways I do. If an encounter ever comes when a semi is in my hand and I what I am doing is wrong, then yes I will take it to court. To go out of my way just to do it in front of a WCO or PGC is not my way of doing things even though it sounds like a taunt from you. Maybe one of these days you all might be in my presence when this happens. But I am not going out of my way to do it. Hunting and trapping not the same. If it was,then once again, clubs,choking, drowning would be illegal also.
Starting to wonder who are the ones against or 2nd ammendment rights? Makes hunters wonders I bet. 2nd ammendment and hunting goes hand and hand.
#16
Thread Starter
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 179
Likes: 0
Be enough for what BT? That I killed a animal after the hunt was over. Once that animal is in the trap the hunt is over. I am no longer hunting that animal. I am dispatching it.I am not looking for my trap or that animal outside my trap. I know exactly where my trap is and where that animal is if it is in my trap. Once that animal is in that trap,again the hunt is over. I use a club a catch pole or drown rigsoften and have only took my semi on my trap line a few times over the years. There is no dispatch regs on animals that are in a trap. Plain and simple there is none.
Does that make sense to anyone at all? Not allowed to dispatch a animal that can't flee or hide that is in a trap useing a semi auto rifle? But are allowed to club drowned or choke them?That is ridiculous. And to enforce that law would make them look like Arses if it was to hit the papers.
Does that make sense to anyone at all? Not allowed to dispatch a animal that can't flee or hide that is in a trap useing a semi auto rifle? But are allowed to club drowned or choke them?That is ridiculous. And to enforce that law would make them look like Arses if it was to hit the papers.
#17
Thread Starter
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 179
Likes: 0
ORIGINAL: WCO R.W.J
Not a taunt at all. However if you feel that your misinterpertation of the law iscorrect, you should have no problem with a WCO tagging along as you violate the law
ORIGINAL: sammy_tat
Again,once an animal iscaught in a trap,the hunt is over.Onlything left to do is dispatch the animal. I will continue to dispatch the ways I do. If an encounter ever comes when a semi is in my hand and I what I am doing is wrong, then yes I will take it to court. To go out of my way just to do it in front of a WCO or PGC is not my way of doing things even though it sounds like a taunt from you. Maybe one of these days you all might be in my presence when this happens. But I am not going out of my way to do it. Hunting and trapping not the same. If it was,then once again, clubs,choking, drowning would be illegal also.
Starting to wonder who are the ones against or 2nd ammendment rights? Makes hunters wonders I bet. 2nd ammendment and hunting goes hand and hand.
Again,once an animal iscaught in a trap,the hunt is over.Onlything left to do is dispatch the animal. I will continue to dispatch the ways I do. If an encounter ever comes when a semi is in my hand and I what I am doing is wrong, then yes I will take it to court. To go out of my way just to do it in front of a WCO or PGC is not my way of doing things even though it sounds like a taunt from you. Maybe one of these days you all might be in my presence when this happens. But I am not going out of my way to do it. Hunting and trapping not the same. If it was,then once again, clubs,choking, drowning would be illegal also.
Starting to wonder who are the ones against or 2nd ammendment rights? Makes hunters wonders I bet. 2nd ammendment and hunting goes hand and hand.
You have failed to show me what is legal to dispatch trapped animals with. So what is legal on trapped animals is also legal for hunting the same animals with I would guess.
#20
Nontypical Buck
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 3,236
Likes: 0
I think the issue is that you can't carry a weapon for trapping that isn't permitted for hunting, because it would open a window for those that wanted to hunt with semis. They could simply claim to be trapping if approached by a WCO.


