Crossbows introduced for regular archery season in PA
#131
RE: Xbow fun
ORIGINAL: Buck Hunter 1
BTB I hope you have been following this thread sometimes. Seems sportsmen and women aren't as impacted by the crossbow and it's usage as your original thread alludes. By the way, I just bought my wife a crossbow and my daughter 10 and i are looking for a suitable one for her. Seems they don't have the armstrngth you have so Xbow is a great opportunity to get us all in the woods together, of course that goes against your grain as Xbows offer to many opportunities for people to go in the woods and crowd "the real hunters". Again, I will huint on Sunday's and w/a Xbow in PA in a very short while. I have just created a $$ income producing opportunity for PAPGC that they will NOT turn down. I am sorry to be so sarcastic, but the bow community has just turned me off w/ these entitlment statements about prowess and practice and special seasons, and whining about people in the woods who don't belong, etc.......... I went through it when I small gamed w/ my bird dog and now because I lean more towards shooting my Xbow than my compound, you guys are banging me again. As I aged in this sport I learned in PA (at least) that it is all about the $$, not the sport. Old saying used in the law enforcement "Follow the money". Good Hunting!
BTB I hope you have been following this thread sometimes. Seems sportsmen and women aren't as impacted by the crossbow and it's usage as your original thread alludes. By the way, I just bought my wife a crossbow and my daughter 10 and i are looking for a suitable one for her. Seems they don't have the armstrngth you have so Xbow is a great opportunity to get us all in the woods together, of course that goes against your grain as Xbows offer to many opportunities for people to go in the woods and crowd "the real hunters". Again, I will huint on Sunday's and w/a Xbow in PA in a very short while. I have just created a $$ income producing opportunity for PAPGC that they will NOT turn down. I am sorry to be so sarcastic, but the bow community has just turned me off w/ these entitlment statements about prowess and practice and special seasons, and whining about people in the woods who don't belong, etc.......... I went through it when I small gamed w/ my bird dog and now because I lean more towards shooting my Xbow than my compound, you guys are banging me again. As I aged in this sport I learned in PA (at least) that it is all about the $$, not the sport. Old saying used in the law enforcement "Follow the money". Good Hunting!
#133
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Ohio,mid
Posts: 1,275
RE: Crossbows introduced for regular archery season in PA
Sproulman & BTB what about the beggining recurve/compound hunting persons?? Should they not take your mandatory class? They do teach some in the Hunters Ed but does that make them proficient w/ a bow? BTB, you make an excellent point.........ut good for the goose, good for the gander.
Sproulman, your responses are always geared to incite harsh responses in most instances:
That is exactly why I will vote for Xbow w/ unfetterd regulation. Entitlement my friend. I always thought those deer were ours , sportsman, PA license holders. Your response verges on the PAPGC thinking that they owned the deer herd. You also resonate superiority in your response that you are the hunters, no one else. Sometimes i read your responses, but most of time your opinion is narrowed and of little value to us (I guess according to your response above) non-hunters. If you aren't seeing deer maybe it is your technique?? I can tell you I see alot of deer, I hunt private, Gamelands and multiple states. I know in my PA property we are trying to kill more deer to keep a healthy herd. But guess what, I changed the way I hunt and the area to see more deer to get that experience. I actually get in the woods early and go deep, I rarely see another hunter in bow, gun when I hunt the Gamelands and if I do see them they are not in as deep as I am. I had to adjust, I do not promote keeping hunters from the field as you seem to be promoting. PA has had nothing but decreases in license sales annually, even with the additional type weapons hunting seasons. But you go a head and keep people new, young, female and others you feel prejudiced towards out of the woods. It will only furhter divide the hunting community, put a bad taste in the mouths of newbies and cause OUR sport to take additional hits from Rendell and his anti's.
Good luck to you BOW HUNTING clubs and hunters that own the wqods.......I will definitely be out there small game hunting, Xbow hunting and in fact here is what i'll do Sproulman, I will ban all recurve and compounds from my camp and property and go only Xbows. I can do that, I own my/the woods!!
Sproulman, your responses are always geared to incite harsh responses in most instances:
ITS NOT CROSSBOW,ITS ALL NEW HUNTERS THAT DID NOT HUNT ARCHERY BEFORE NOW HUNTING VERY FEW DEER THAT ARE LEFT WITH A GREAT CHANCE OF HARVESTING THAT BUCK THAT A RECURVE/COMPOUND HUNTER HAD TO THEMSELVES.
call it selfish by us hunters,YES,no doubt about that too.
call it selfish by us hunters,YES,no doubt about that too.
Good luck to you BOW HUNTING clubs and hunters that own the wqods.......I will definitely be out there small game hunting, Xbow hunting and in fact here is what i'll do Sproulman, I will ban all recurve and compounds from my camp and property and go only Xbows. I can do that, I own my/the woods!!
#134
RE: Crossbows introduced for regular archery season in PA
I beleive I did say mandatory ed for ALL new bowhunters no matter what weapon. A guy who buys a crossbow, a recurve or a compound a week before the season doesnt belong in the woods with that weapon till he has put in some time learning his sport.
Mandatory bowhunter-ed for ALL is long overdue
Mandatory bowhunter-ed for ALL is long overdue
#135
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Ohio,mid
Posts: 1,275
RE: Crossbows introduced for regular archery season in PA
BTBowhunter, sorry. Overeacted there. You did say ALL! In North Park in Pittsburgh you have ot shoot proficiency in order to join the special hunt. Huge deer in that park.
#136
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Apr 2004
Posts: 3,236
RE: Crossbows introduced for regular archery season in PA
I think crossguns should be welcomed into any gun season.
I shudder to think that ARCHERY season will get shortened back to October only.
I really don't begin to hunt until the last week of October. For me, archery "bow and arrow" season is all about that magical window of time from around October 20th-November 15ish.
Shortening the season will wreck mine and my families' world.
All I can say.
I did have two crossgun trespassers (2B) come under my stand last season looking for a doe they wounded. I found it weeks later. They didn't.[:@]
I shudder to think that ARCHERY season will get shortened back to October only.
I really don't begin to hunt until the last week of October. For me, archery "bow and arrow" season is all about that magical window of time from around October 20th-November 15ish.
Shortening the season will wreck mine and my families' world.
All I can say.
I did have two crossgun trespassers (2B) come under my stand last season looking for a doe they wounded. I found it weeks later. They didn't.[:@]
#137
RE: Crossbows introduced for regular archery season in PA
ORIGINAL: livbucks
I think crossguns should be welcomed into any gun season.
I shudder to think that ARCHERY season will get shortened back to October only.
I really don't begin to hunt until the last week of October. For me, archery "bow and arrow" season is all about that magical window of time from around October 20th-November 15ish.
Shortening the season will wreck mine and my families' world.
All I can say.
I did have two crossgun trespassers (2B) come under my stand last season looking for a doe they wounded. I found it weeks later. They didn't.[:@]
I think crossguns should be welcomed into any gun season.
I shudder to think that ARCHERY season will get shortened back to October only.
I really don't begin to hunt until the last week of October. For me, archery "bow and arrow" season is all about that magical window of time from around October 20th-November 15ish.
Shortening the season will wreck mine and my families' world.
All I can say.
I did have two crossgun trespassers (2B) come under my stand last season looking for a doe they wounded. I found it weeks later. They didn't.[:@]
JMHO
#138
RE: Crossbows introduced for regular archery season in PA
ORIGINAL: Buck Hunter 1
BTBowhunter, sorry. Overeacted there. You did say ALL! In North Park in Pittsburgh you have ot shoot proficiency in order to join the special hunt. Huge deer in that park.
BTBowhunter, sorry. Overeacted there. You did say ALL! In North Park in Pittsburgh you have ot shoot proficiency in order to join the special hunt. Huge deer in that park.
#139
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Apr 2004
Posts: 3,236
RE: Crossbows introduced for regular archery season in PA
ORIGINAL: BTBowhunter
I think our concerns are exactly the same here Greg. We are both concerned that allowing an "easy way" to get into the early season could result in a shorter season. So far, the challenges of hunting with archery equipment and committment required keeps out those looking for the "short cut" .Considering the unrelenting onslaught from crossbow manufacturers and with an apparently growing acceptancefor the things, maybe our energies would be better served in pushing now for mandatory bowhunter education. I sincerely believe it will deter the throngs of one day wonders from plunking down the $$ for a crossbow just to find an easy way into the bow season.
JMHO
ORIGINAL: livbucks
I think crossguns should be welcomed into any gun season.
I shudder to think that ARCHERY season will get shortened back to October only.
I really don't begin to hunt until the last week of October. For me, archery "bow and arrow" season is all about that magical window of time from around October 20th-November 15ish.
Shortening the season will wreck mine and my families' world.
All I can say.
I did have two crossgun trespassers (2B) come under my stand last season looking for a doe they wounded. I found it weeks later. They didn't.[:@]
I think crossguns should be welcomed into any gun season.
I shudder to think that ARCHERY season will get shortened back to October only.
I really don't begin to hunt until the last week of October. For me, archery "bow and arrow" season is all about that magical window of time from around October 20th-November 15ish.
Shortening the season will wreck mine and my families' world.
All I can say.
I did have two crossgun trespassers (2B) come under my stand last season looking for a doe they wounded. I found it weeks later. They didn't.[:@]
JMHO
True, the crossgun does not have a more effective range than a bow, but the learning curve to crossguns is so much shorter, and the perception of effectiveness so greater, that a huge number of otherwise one-day gun hunters will jump in to the archery season. The GC will no doubt react by shortening the season.
I have seen it first hand. In 2B last season I had a duo come to me, trespassing no less, looking for a doe they wounded. I almost never see other hunters encroaching on the area I hunt during archery season. Their crossguns were brand new, I wonder how long they practiced??..
A person can pick up a crossgun, and in a matter of minutes, be hitting the proverbial pie plate. What makes that any different that shooting a gun, besides a shorter range. Nothing.
I just don't think they belong in bow and arrow season. The cost to the whole concept of archery "bow and arrow" season will be lost. Lost to the fast-food, push-to-talk, on-demand, instant gratification new age world.
I can visualize the archery season morphing into just a more quieter gun season. And worse...shorter.
#140
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Apr 2004
Posts: 3,236
RE: Crossbows introduced for regular archery season in PA
At one time I was adamantly opposed to their use in regular archery season but I'm backing away from that position due to a lack of evidence that it has negatively impacted season lenghth or tag allocationsanywhere it's been used.
The fact that all the pressure is coming from manufacturers is seriously disturbing. They are only concerned with creating a market for the product. How can that be good in the scheme of things?