Property owners and PGC laws collide
02-14-2007 | 12:27 PM
#52
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 196
Likes: 0
RE: Property owners and PGC laws collide
HUH?
Don't know who you are talking to there Gerorge. If it's me please tell "my agency" to send a paycheck. 
But I am done talking to someone who should never be a PGC officer. Someone who is arrogant as you and your words should never be given any power of law inforcement.
02-14-2007 | 12:42 PM
#53
Nontypical Buck
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 2,262
Likes: 0
RE: Property owners and PGC laws collide
Hunting is a privledge in Pa and you have to abide by the laws if you want to play.Hhow hard is that to understand.Murder is illegal.You can't just kill someone because you're on your own property.
02-14-2007 | 12:54 PM
#54
Host of Hosts
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 5,780
Likes: 0
From: Erie, Pennsylvania
RE: Property owners and PGC laws collide
We own 164 acres. How do PGC laws apply to land owners?
Just wanted some input on this to see how others feel about land owners rights and some of the PGC laws.
Just thought I would stir the pot up some.
Just wanted some input on this to see how others feel about land owners rights and some of the PGC laws.
Just thought I would stir the pot up some.
You said in the opening of your post that you wanted to know how laws applied to land owners then you asked how others feel about the laws. Ever since you've been trying to convince us that its OK to break laws, because you own land. Go ahead break any law you want, get a lawyer to fight the constitutionality of the laws, whatever, but don't ask for opinions then refuse to acknowledge anyones posts as valid. You are going to disagree regardless, that is now plain to see.
Why everyone has to blame the PGC on every issue under the sun is beyond me. The legislature gave them the authorities they have why isn't anyone bashing them? They do their jobs just like you and I go to work everyday. They are ordinary people just like we are trying their best to perform a job. Give them a break already. The PGC isn't to blame for everything going on in Pa. like some on this Northeast forum would have us believe. Uneducatedhunters are more of a problem in Pa than the PGC could ever be.
02-14-2007 | 01:04 PM
#56
Thread Starter
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 189
Likes: 0
RE: Property owners and PGC laws collide
ORIGINAL: DougE
Hunting is a privledge in Pa and you have to abide by the laws if you want to play.Hhow hard is that to understand.Murder is illegal.You can't just kill someone because you're on your own property.
Hunting is a privledge in Pa and you have to abide by the laws if you want to play.Hhow hard is that to understand.Murder is illegal.You can't just kill someone because you're on your own property.
Compare oranges to a brick. Killing someone compared to useing what one wants to hunt with on his own property. We land owners do not have to hunt or use the same guidelines as public land hunters. Akid under 16 doesn't have to have an adult with him to hunt his own land. But on public he does. So don't tell me all the laws are the same for property owners as general public they are not. So we do have our own extra rights and what is permissable on our own property. And what we wear and use is our choice also. Now if we don't have extra rights as a land owner explain this under 16 law and property owners? And it goes beyond that law also. I can shoot a deer outside my truck window on my property or shoot it from the upstairs window of my house. These are property owners rights. So don't tell me we have to apply by the same laws.
02-14-2007 | 01:13 PM
#57
Thread Starter
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 189
Likes: 0
RE: Property owners and PGC laws collide
ORIGINAL: TRYKONOISSEUR
It is now obvious george that your last line I quoted there is all your up to. Stirring the pot.
You said in the opening of your post that you wanted to know how laws applied to land owners then you asked how others feel about the laws. Ever since you've been trying to convince us that its OK to break laws, because you own land. Go ahead break any law you want, get a lawyer to fight the constitutionality of the laws, whatever, but don't ask for opinions then refuse to acknowledge anyones posts as valid. You are going to disagree regardless, that is now plain to see.
Why everyone has to blame the PGC on every issue under the sun is beyond me. The legislature gave them the authorities they have why isn't anyone bashing them? They do their jobs just like you and I go to work everyday. They are ordinary people just like we are trying their best to perform a job. Give them a break already. The PGC isn't to blame for everything going on in Pa. like some on this Northeast forum would have us believe. Uneducatedhunters are more of a problem in Pa than the PGC could ever be.
We own 164 acres. How do PGC laws apply to land owners?
Just wanted some input on this to see how others feel about land owners rights and some of the PGC laws.
Just thought I would stir the pot up some.
Just wanted some input on this to see how others feel about land owners rights and some of the PGC laws.
Just thought I would stir the pot up some.
You said in the opening of your post that you wanted to know how laws applied to land owners then you asked how others feel about the laws. Ever since you've been trying to convince us that its OK to break laws, because you own land. Go ahead break any law you want, get a lawyer to fight the constitutionality of the laws, whatever, but don't ask for opinions then refuse to acknowledge anyones posts as valid. You are going to disagree regardless, that is now plain to see.
Why everyone has to blame the PGC on every issue under the sun is beyond me. The legislature gave them the authorities they have why isn't anyone bashing them? They do their jobs just like you and I go to work everyday. They are ordinary people just like we are trying their best to perform a job. Give them a break already. The PGC isn't to blame for everything going on in Pa. like some on this Northeast forum would have us believe. Uneducatedhunters are more of a problem in Pa than the PGC could ever be.
02-14-2007 | 01:22 PM
#58
Host of Hosts
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 5,780
Likes: 0
From: Erie, Pennsylvania
RE: Property owners and PGC laws collide
Wipe the brown off your nose there tryk
Oh that's mature of you... But I guess I'd expect that from you considering the pattern your posts have taken. Your acting like a 12 year old who can't have his way. BOOO HOOO, I want to hunt with a semi auto and not wear orange, cause I'm a land owner Bla Bla Bla.... Let me ask you! Why do you think your special and deserve to be treated differently than anyone else?
02-14-2007 | 01:37 PM
#59
Host of Hosts
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 5,780
Likes: 0
From: Erie, Pennsylvania
RE: Property owners and PGC laws collide
But this was about a debate on choice of weapons,or clothing and other small laws that prohibit land owners from use
Should you be allowed to use a .50 cal for your deer hunting? After all it is adequate!