I'd have to keep my Remington Model 760 pump action 30-06.

I find it really hard to beat the Weatherby Ultra Light weight MArk V rifle.

springfield 1908 30/06. old but reliable not pretty either but i like it..will prob keep gun but up grad stock trigger etc..

Rem 700 LSS .300wm
Rem 700 VLS .308
Rem 700 VS .308
Rem 700 Sendero 7mmmag
Rem 700 Mountain .270
Rem 870 Express Magnum Police/Tactical 12 gauge
Rem 870 Wingmaster 12 gauge
Rem 11-87 12 gauge

Can I pick a shotgun and rifle? I feel so dirty even thinking about this [:'(]

I'd keep the 870 Express due to all the gizmos and barrels I have for/on it. And probably keep the Sendero, although I'd replace it with the new Sendero I'm getting in .300RUM when they hit stores in a couple weeks.

I hate you all for making me chose!

I take it all back! They all stay! I love them all!!!!

I need therapy now

Sig Sauer!

If I had a Sig rifle, I may say the same. Now if the question was which pistol we'd keep, my Sig would definitely be the answer

Well I got my rifle for a great price in Germany, half what it would have cost there or here in states. And i love it...... now if NY had different laws I would probably have me a Sig pistol too!

If I could have only one gun it would have to be my Ruger mark 2 government target model .22! With this I wouldn't starve to death and could also do a fair job of defending my family. But since we are just doing what iff,s I'll keep my 30-06, .270,.308 tactial,45-70 marlin,.223 varmint couple of SKS,s MAC90 two glocks two Kel Tec,s Super Blackhawk and some other stuff cause I'm a gun nut!

My 700 BDL .243

Limited to one, I'd keep my sported Sweede mauser in 6.5 X 55.
I've owned/ carried her for years, never let me down, and there's nothing like the first one you get..
Saying goodbye to the others would be the harder to do than choosing the one..