Feathers vs. Vanes
#1
Feathers vs. Vanes
I shoot vanes now and was thinking about going to feathers. I would be target shooting in my backyard and a little 3d. What are some of the benefits of feathers?
#2
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Raven Creek, PA
Posts: 304
RE: Feathers vs. Vanes
This is right from the back page of Bowhunting World.
Advantages of Vanes:
- More weather resistent
- Easier to attach to shafts
- Quiter in brush and in flight
- Generaly more durable
- Less expensive than feathers
- More weight and less air resistance provides greater arrow energy and speed at longer ranges
Advantages of Feathers
- Larger surface area gives more air resistance and generaly greater arrow control
- More flexible: less likely to be knocked off course after striking bow components or branches
- Generaly considered more traditional and aesthetically pleasing
- Less weight gives greater arrow speed at shorter ranges.
Advantages of Vanes:
- More weather resistent
- Easier to attach to shafts
- Quiter in brush and in flight
- Generaly more durable
- Less expensive than feathers
- More weight and less air resistance provides greater arrow energy and speed at longer ranges
Advantages of Feathers
- Larger surface area gives more air resistance and generaly greater arrow control
- More flexible: less likely to be knocked off course after striking bow components or branches
- Generaly considered more traditional and aesthetically pleasing
- Less weight gives greater arrow speed at shorter ranges.
#3
RE: Feathers vs. Vanes
Feathers or Vanes?
Feathers or Vanes and Why?
Feathers or Vanes??
? For the Folks Who Have Used Both Feathers and Vanes
Vanes or Feathers?
Just a few that I found out of the first 300 results.
Forums | HELP | RULES | Register | Login | My Profile
Gallery | Member List | Search | Lost Password | Log Out
Chat | Classifieds | Hunt Swap | Contact Admin
ACTIVE TOPICS | InBox
Feathers or Vanes and Why?
Feathers or Vanes??
? For the Folks Who Have Used Both Feathers and Vanes
Vanes or Feathers?
Just a few that I found out of the first 300 results.
Forums | HELP | RULES | Register | Login | My Profile
Gallery | Member List | Search | Lost Password | Log Out
Chat | Classifieds | Hunt Swap | Contact Admin
ACTIVE TOPICS | InBox
#4
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location:
Posts: 86
RE: Feathers vs. Vanes
I would have to agree with the top answer as referring you to the bowhunting mag..
But as any thoughts to this subject....I switched from feathers"5" to vanes"4" and seen little to no differance. If the bow is tuned with respectable reason....my group that I hunt with are swapping arrows of differnt types and sizes to see the differnaces. WE dont really notice anything for hunting....
Next thought is notice the differnces in the material of the vanes and styles (NAP has one out that spins the arrow more which I really dont get). If need I will dig up that bowhunting world and get my typing fingers working....it is a great read.
Thanks
But as any thoughts to this subject....I switched from feathers"5" to vanes"4" and seen little to no differance. If the bow is tuned with respectable reason....my group that I hunt with are swapping arrows of differnt types and sizes to see the differnaces. WE dont really notice anything for hunting....
Next thought is notice the differnces in the material of the vanes and styles (NAP has one out that spins the arrow more which I really dont get). If need I will dig up that bowhunting world and get my typing fingers working....it is a great read.
Thanks
#5
Giant Nontypical
Join Date: Feb 2003
Posts: 9,175
RE: Feathers vs. Vanes
You just about have to hog tie me to the rack and stick red hot irons to my flesh to get me to use vanes any more. Last time I willingly stuck vanes on an arrow was to test some of those new Bohning Blazers for the pro shop I shoot for.
I haven't looked at the links to the topics Washington Hunter posted, but I'm sure you'll find my opinions in at least a few of 'em.
I haven't looked at the links to the topics Washington Hunter posted, but I'm sure you'll find my opinions in at least a few of 'em.
#7
RE: Feathers vs. Vanes
One thing not mentioned yet is that feathers are more forgiving of mistakes. Since we're not machines and our form isn't always perfect, I shoot feathers. Stabilizes the arrow faster and better. Oh, and they are faster than vanes. Contrary to what some say.
#8
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Tulsa, Oklahoma
Posts: 1,051
RE: Feathers vs. Vanes
and they are faster than vanes. Contrary to what some say.
I tried feathers several years ago and I just couldn't get the darn things weather proof. I sprayed them, dipped them, rubbed powder in them, and the first drizzle that came along flattened them out every time. Vanes are fool proof. Even if you punch a hole in one practising, just clip it out and keep on keepin' on.
#9
Giant Nontypical
Join Date: Feb 2003
Posts: 9,175
RE: Feathers vs. Vanes
Vanes are fool proof.
With those teeny little fletches target archers use, there isn't enough drag to pull a pissant off a toilet seat. The difference in trajectory is caused by lower FOC, which is caused by vanes weighing a good 3X more than feathers. That holds true for hunting length fletching as well, IMO.