I mean really.....
#71
Giant Nontypical
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 6,679
Likes: 0
From: Heaven is my home, temporarily residing in WNY :)
ORIGINAL: MichiganWhitetails74
What's all this talk about MW? Has there been some bashing going on ?
What's all this talk about MW? Has there been some bashing going on ?
....I loves ya lots! No Bashing ....
#72
No real desire for me to arrow a giraffe, but thats just me, for me I think there's plenty of big game to hunt in North America...but like one said whatever floats your boat. My eyes are dead set on brown bear, so everyone has their dream game in mind whether it be Africa or Canada or Alaska.
#73
If you hunt giraffes you don't need a tree stand you need a stepladder
I saw the show you guys are refering to. It was cool how they were looking for blood 6-8 ft. up on the trees.
The tanned hide would be quite a conversation piece.

I saw the show you guys are refering to. It was cool how they were looking for blood 6-8 ft. up on the trees.
The tanned hide would be quite a conversation piece.
#74
Typical Buck
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 818
Likes: 0
From: RAYVILLE,LA.
ORIGINAL: Paul L Mohr
I didn't read all the posts, but here is my take on it. It's trophy hunting pure and simple. You shoot one because you have the money and you want to do it because you can say you did it and it would look cool in your trophy room or something.
In my opinion it is no different than someone that purely trophy hunts for deer. If you are waiting for the perfect mature buck with a monster rack so you can take a bunch of pictures, have it mounted and show it off in your home it's the same exact thing. Your not doing it to feed your family or thin out the herd, because if you were you wouldn't be passing up deer until you found the right one, or you would be shooting does as well.
Not saying if I think it's right or wrong or if you should or shouldn't do it, just my take on it.
I would personally have no desire to do it though.
Paul
I didn't read all the posts, but here is my take on it. It's trophy hunting pure and simple. You shoot one because you have the money and you want to do it because you can say you did it and it would look cool in your trophy room or something.
In my opinion it is no different than someone that purely trophy hunts for deer. If you are waiting for the perfect mature buck with a monster rack so you can take a bunch of pictures, have it mounted and show it off in your home it's the same exact thing. Your not doing it to feed your family or thin out the herd, because if you were you wouldn't be passing up deer until you found the right one, or you would be shooting does as well.
Not saying if I think it's right or wrong or if you should or shouldn't do it, just my take on it.
I would personally have no desire to do it though.
Paul
#76
I hope this helps to put things into perspective. Here's a little twist that might help you understand the whole process.
In Africa, 10% of the population have jobs. That 10% works for about $30 US dollars per month. A giraffe (as part of a conservation effort) brings in about $3500-$4500. That's a month's salary for 35-45 individuals. Let say those individuals areAK-47 totingmembers of an anti-poaching organization. Seems the governments there cannot collect enough taxes to pay for these blokes for their dedicated service. Hmmm... the money has to come from somewhere, right?The governmentsdo not sell enough resident and non-resident hunting licenses to provide the funds. Nor, do they collect enough excise tax on sporting equipment and ammunition to adequately provide for the wildlife and those that protect it. Heck,Most governments, within Africa,barely make ends meet feeding their citizens.
It's easy fora man can become an internationalhunter and a conservationist within the same moment (a "win-win" situation 99% of the time). Without such individuals....God help us!
Va,"giving" in Africa is as important as "taking". Sometimes, that's all you really need to know. Me personally...I would take a giraffe if there wasn't anything else to give. By the way, they are far from being endangered and can be a real pain in the arse!They are one of the preferred foods of lions...
In Africa, 10% of the population have jobs. That 10% works for about $30 US dollars per month. A giraffe (as part of a conservation effort) brings in about $3500-$4500. That's a month's salary for 35-45 individuals. Let say those individuals areAK-47 totingmembers of an anti-poaching organization. Seems the governments there cannot collect enough taxes to pay for these blokes for their dedicated service. Hmmm... the money has to come from somewhere, right?The governmentsdo not sell enough resident and non-resident hunting licenses to provide the funds. Nor, do they collect enough excise tax on sporting equipment and ammunition to adequately provide for the wildlife and those that protect it. Heck,Most governments, within Africa,barely make ends meet feeding their citizens.
It's easy fora man can become an internationalhunter and a conservationist within the same moment (a "win-win" situation 99% of the time). Without such individuals....God help us!
Va,"giving" in Africa is as important as "taking". Sometimes, that's all you really need to know. Me personally...I would take a giraffe if there wasn't anything else to give. By the way, they are far from being endangered and can be a real pain in the arse!They are one of the preferred foods of lions...
#79
Giant Nontypical
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 7,876
Likes: 0
From: Ohio
ORIGINAL: Vabowman
I just think it's silly to shoot a giraffe, not saying it shouldn't be done if that's what needs to be done, but out of all the animals in Africa, I just thought a giraffe was strange, never heard of anyone eating giraffe.
I just think it's silly to shoot a giraffe, not saying it shouldn't be done if that's what needs to be done, but out of all the animals in Africa, I just thought a giraffe was strange, never heard of anyone eating giraffe.
The one my sister inlaw took was use to feed the captive lions they had. 1 Every 3 days is needed. She's getting a neck up mount done and the hide will be used for other things. I think they were having some stools made of the feet from a bull elephant my brother took (how do you feel about ivory

). The giraff hide will be the seat part. She also took a zebra and their having a rug made out of it.It's one thing to not understand something, it's another thing entirely speak against it. I know some people who are against hunting and your opening statement was almost word for word with what they've said. One of them actually prayed God would surround the giraffs so that my sister inlaw would miss.
God must be a hunter aye!
#80
ORIGINAL: brucelanthier
I guess the gnats were really annoying here 
http://www.huntingnet.com//forum/tm.aspx?m=2788796
Perhaps they thought it was silly for someone to want to hunt with a bow
ORIGINAL: NEW61375
We know they(antis) are there, kind of like gnats. Enough to really annoy you but not enough to force you into hiding or abandon your beliefs.
We know they(antis) are there, kind of like gnats. Enough to really annoy you but not enough to force you into hiding or abandon your beliefs.

http://www.huntingnet.com//forum/tm.aspx?m=2788796
Perhaps they thought it was silly for someone to want to hunt with a bow
Many people on here are correct in statingpeople hunt for different reasons. You may want to hunt for rhinos in Africa and I may hunt turkeys in VA. Just because I do not have any urge to hunt rhinos or giraffes or whatever does not mean I oppose you itmight justI can't relate to it, I don't have the urge to do it, it's not somthing I have been exposed to, or it just seems odd to me. No big deal the antis didn't recruit me I just don't get it.You can explain it to me and I might say ok, but that doesn't mean I view it any differently, I don't like baiting, I don't like high fences, I don't want to do exotic foreign country hunting for a trophy. None of those are my thing, maybe they are yours, good luck with them, I honestly don't think VA was bashing it just stating that he didn't see the point, and I would have to agree with him somewhat.
What's more important is that what we think doesn't amount to much, just our back-woods VA opinions based on our exposure to hunting. It doesn't mean we want to ban giraffe hunting, we just think giraffes are goofy.
Especially that one at Toys-R-Us, what a dork he is, now that I think about it, I'd shoot him.



