View Poll Results: A poll
Voters: 161. You may not vote on this poll
For or Against Mandatory Bowhunter Education
#103
Fork Horn
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 298
Likes: 0
ORIGINAL: txjourneyman
Does this include manually operated lawn equipment or just gas/electric?
Does this include manually operated lawn equipment or just gas/electric?
#104
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 106
Likes: 0
From:
ORIGINAL: Badger_Girl93
I honestly don't know any specific stats...so excuse me for speculating. But I suspect that there are far more injuries, fatalities, and property damage from the use of lawn and garden tools than there are from bowhunting activities. Yet, lawn and garden tool safety is not managed by the state. Perhaps I am wrong....if so, my bad.
Weapon safety is taught in general hunter's ed classes (which I am in favor of), so I don't agree that a separate bow hunter specific course is required to teachweapon safety. JMO
ORIGINAL: Goodgrief
Yes there is a difference in my humble opinion. We are talking about giving safety instructions for a weapon that is designed to kill, that does not discriminate in the path of the projectile, that is left up to the brain behind the trigger. If the brain does not know how to operate this weapon it could have fatal consequences to not only the user but those around the user. I gave all my children, extensive instruction in safety and operation of the lawn mower before they used it. I am proud to say, they have never fell out of a tree stand, trying to rake leaves, with razors attached to metal sticks. HUH? Apples and Oranges.
Yes there is a difference in my humble opinion. We are talking about giving safety instructions for a weapon that is designed to kill, that does not discriminate in the path of the projectile, that is left up to the brain behind the trigger. If the brain does not know how to operate this weapon it could have fatal consequences to not only the user but those around the user. I gave all my children, extensive instruction in safety and operation of the lawn mower before they used it. I am proud to say, they have never fell out of a tree stand, trying to rake leaves, with razors attached to metal sticks. HUH? Apples and Oranges.
Weapon safety is taught in general hunter's ed classes (which I am in favor of), so I don't agree that a separate bow hunter specific course is required to teachweapon safety. JMO
#105
LOL.
Aside from what I have commented on before.
I would say that having bowhunting education courses mandatory could only help the perception of how non-hunting hunters (not PETA, they are a different bunch) perceive hunters. Which is important IMO.
Aside from what I have commented on before.
I would say that having bowhunting education courses mandatory could only help the perception of how non-hunting hunters (not PETA, they are a different bunch) perceive hunters. Which is important IMO.
#106
Fork Horn
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 298
Likes: 0
ORIGINAL: Goodgrief
The total number of households and commercial buildings in a state that require the use of these tools, combined with the number of operators of these intruments, I think is a much greater number, than the number of bowhunters in the state. Statistically speculating.
The total number of households and commercial buildings in a state that require the use of these tools, combined with the number of operators of these intruments, I think is a much greater number, than the number of bowhunters in the state. Statistically speculating.
#107
I dont see why not, i had to take one in order to hunt here in NY. Its not like its torture or anything, sit around and talking hunting for about 8 hours wheres the harm in that??
#109
ORIGINAL: BobCo19-65
LOL.
Aside from what I have commented on before.
I would say that having bowhunting education courses mandatory could only help the perception of how non-hunting hunters (not PETA, they are a different bunch) perceive hunters. Which is important IMO.
LOL.
Aside from what I have commented on before.
I would say that having bowhunting education courses mandatory could only help the perception of how non-hunting hunters (not PETA, they are a different bunch) perceive hunters. Which is important IMO.
#110
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 106
Likes: 0
From:
ORIGINAL: Badger_Girl93
EXACTLY!...That is my point, there is minimal (none?)state mandated skills and safety training for private operation of lawn tools....despite the fact that it impacts so many people....so then why should there be state mandated training for something (bowhunting) that impacts relatively few people?
ORIGINAL: Goodgrief
The total number of households and commercial buildings in a state that require the use of these tools, combined with the number of operators of these intruments, I think is a much greater number, than the number of bowhunters in the state. Statistically speculating.
The total number of households and commercial buildings in a state that require the use of these tools, combined with the number of operators of these intruments, I think is a much greater number, than the number of bowhunters in the state. Statistically speculating.










[8D]