Back in the early 80's I used to hunt outside of Kerrville, Tx. I remember taking my deer to the taxidermist and seeing guys buy 10 point racks (sheds) for as much as $10,000 and have them mounted and sent to their homes. They would never set 1 foot in the woods.

I'm not sure if this has been covered. If you shoot the deer in a high fence preserve would it still qualify for P&Y? If so thats a crock cuz P&Y and B&C are for fair chase or am I naive?

I don't think it would qualify, but it would be so easy to get it scored and entered. They don't ask if theirwas fences up or not.

Seems like there should be something to that effect.

Both P & Y and B&C require the animal to be fairchase. Which would not include a fence. They also require a witness to attest to it.

I just emailed the clown and told him what I thought about his style!

I actually recieved an email back this morning from them. If I can figure out how to insert it on here I will.

Here is the email i got in response to the one i sent about hunting in fences!!





I’m assuming you are referring to the recent show from Ohio? That’s the show where we filmed the father who bought his son – you know, the one who just returned from Iraq – a hunt. Keith hunted an entirely different location and was successful in his hunt and it wasn’t part of the fenced operation you saw. So by all means email our sponsors and make sure you express your dissatisfaction. Let them know that a grateful father shouldn’t have the right to buy his son a hunt. A son who served, sacrificed and defended YOUR freedoms, shouldn’t be given such a gift. The fact that we filmed it an aired it? My response to that? TOUGH! You don’t like it? TURN THE CHANNEL! That young man’s service, sacrifice and commitment to freedom gives you that privilege as well.
Have a nice day.
Roger Bales – Forum Manager

I guess if your in the military, a police officer or a fireman, its ok to shoot penned deer.

Kieth and Allan "Anything for a Nickle" Warren. I hold them both to the highest degree of contempt.