WB or Fall/Drop-Away?
04-05-2007 | 01:02 PM
#51
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 4,668
Likes: 0
From: NY
RE: WB or Fall/Drop-Away?
ORIGINAL: GMMAT
I'm sorry I overlooked this response to the above....because it's SPOT-ON!
It's HONEST, too......
That is the most rediculous thing I have ever read...........I ask open questions here all the time.........and I read each and every reply and lend no greater value to one over another based on what I think of that persons hunting abilities................that is just stupid.
To me this thiking is flawed. When I am seeking advice from people I want expert opinions. That doesn't mean I don't respect everyone else's opinion, but I will put more stock in someone that is experienced rather than a new person. For example, I would have more emphasis on something that Davidmil or Len had to say rather than some of our young teenage members. That not a knock on the young guys, but Len and David have over 200 deer between them easily. To me that makes their opinion a little more valuable.
So why should anyone ever respond to one of your questions then........knowing that there is a good chance you will totally dismiss their opinion because you don't regard them as an "expert"?
04-05-2007 | 01:04 PM
#52
Thread Starter
Dominant Buck
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 21,043
Likes: 0
From:
RE: WB or Fall/Drop-Away?
OK, then, Atlas....we can do it your way.
Start a poll on what it takes to get close and get a shot at a mature whitetail buck.......say 3.5 yr old and older. Tell me you wouldn't weigh the comments, based on the poster (it's NATURAL).
For ****s and giggles.....why not post up your experiences to start us off on the right foot. I'm sure EVERY member will be on the edge of their seats at your response......and will put JUST as much credence in YOUR answer as they do gregH; Len; Davidmil and germs.
Start a poll on what it takes to get close and get a shot at a mature whitetail buck.......say 3.5 yr old and older. Tell me you wouldn't weigh the comments, based on the poster (it's NATURAL).
For ****s and giggles.....why not post up your experiences to start us off on the right foot. I'm sure EVERY member will be on the edge of their seats at your response......and will put JUST as much credence in YOUR answer as they do gregH; Len; Davidmil and germs.
04-05-2007 | 01:07 PM
#54
Thread Starter
Dominant Buck
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 21,043
Likes: 0
From:
RE: WB or Fall/Drop-Away?
Atlas....this board isn't a popularity contest. They don't know. If they care that much....they can CLICK and pass.
Are you saying you'd take the Little League pitcher's advice on how to hit the slider? you'd lend it JUST as much credence as the ML hitter?
Honestly?????
Are you saying you'd take the Little League pitcher's advice on how to hit the slider? you'd lend it JUST as much credence as the ML hitter?
Honestly?????
Let's grow up guys!
04-05-2007 | 01:37 PM
#60
Thread Starter
Dominant Buck
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 21,043
Likes: 0
From:
RE: WB or Fall/Drop-Away?
Then explain this to me, Turtle....
According to Atlas....you're playing No. 12 at Augusta.....and your playing partners are a 20hcp who plays 4 times a year.....and a 9 yr old that's never played. You ask everyone which club they think you ought to hit.....and the CONSENSUS is a driver.
You're a scratch player....and Phil Mickelson (your other playing partner) is going with a nine.
Do you hit driver?
If not....you've WEIGHED your responses (based on the expertise of the individual advice given) and you'll make your decision on that. You still grabbing that head cover????
According to Atlas....you're playing No. 12 at Augusta.....and your playing partners are a 20hcp who plays 4 times a year.....and a 9 yr old that's never played. You ask everyone which club they think you ought to hit.....and the CONSENSUS is a driver.
You're a scratch player....and Phil Mickelson (your other playing partner) is going with a nine.
Do you hit driver?
If not....you've WEIGHED your responses (based on the expertise of the individual advice given) and you'll make your decision on that. You still grabbing that head cover????