I don't plan on bothering with them, but if the thought was that genetics payed a part in having two deer like this, I would let my nephew shoot em. Thanks.

I wouldn't jump to a bad genetics theory at all. Just looks like a couple young bucks that are only 1.5 yr olds. They will get bigger. Relax and don't worry about it.

if it was around here id shoot it because any deer with antlers around here is a shooter!

doesnt look like a very old deer...maybe his children follow the same genetic line, as far as starting as a spike, lack of nutrition will do that. I'd make sure it was the same deer as the previous year before you take him out.

Oh, I don't plan on shooting him. I have my eyes set on three others. Just wanting some input. I could see staring out as a spike, but spike on one side, something much shorter/messed up, on the other side just seemed odd.Thanks for the input.