try a smokepole
#1
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: nj pines
Posts: 6
try a smokepole
As a proud owner of full line of t/c ml s i left my black diamond w/ power belts and pyrodex home ,,and took out my old hawkin goex and round balls i must have let 30 does and small bucks walk by ,,,until the morning of jan.3 2005 ,the first deer i seen that morning was a big doe behind her was 11pt. that have nt seen since aug.i was sure another bow hunter got him ...i took that nice buck with the ole smokepole and it was great ,,,,,,so next time you head out dont forget the smokepole (if you have one ).
#5
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: S Texas
Posts: 1,037
RE: try a smokepole
Side hammers, real BP and round balls ARE muzzle loading, IMO. Might as well shoot a cartridge gun as shoot a scoped inline. Flame away, guys, but that is my belief! Nothing like a kill using the old ways.
#9
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location:
Posts: 91
RE: try a smokepole
I have three muzzloaders, a Lyman Great Plains rifle, a Thompson Center Whitemountain Carbine, and just recently a Knight Revolution, my first inline. The Lyman Great Plains rifle and the White Mountain Carbine are both sidehammers and I have peep sites mounted on both. The Lyman is the traditional Hawken style with a long barrel with a slow twist and double triggers. The T/C has a short barrel with a fast twist and single trigger. I have shot many deer with the Whitemountain carbine and like how it drops them stone dead with a 385 grain great plains bullet. The longest shot that I have made with either is 70yds. with the T/C. I like shooting my traditional style muzzloaders, but I am not a big fan of hunting with a patched roundball. I just don't think that it does as good of a job as a heavy sabot/pistol bullet or a maxiball. I shot a doe with a roundball once and had a long, sparse bloodtrail. I eventually found the deer, but it was a long recovery. The ball was placed perfectly just behind the shoulder. It pierced both lungs and nicked the heart. I found the ball just under the skin on the far side of the carcass. With maxiballs and jacketed bullets, I have complete passthroughs. Congrats on your nice buck and I would also like to see a picture!
#10
Fork Horn
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location:
Posts: 102
RE: try a smokepole
ORIGINAL: Viking_hunter
I like shooting my traditional style muzzloaders, but I am not a big fan of hunting with a patched roundball. I just don't think that it does as good of a job as a heavy sabot/pistol bullet or a maxiball. I shot a doe with a roundball once and had a long, sparse bloodtrail. I eventually found the deer, but it was a long recovery. The ball was placed perfectly just behind the shoulder. It pierced both lungs and nicked the heart. I found the ball just under the skin on the far side of the carcass. With maxiballs and jacketed bullets, I have complete passthroughs.
I like shooting my traditional style muzzloaders, but I am not a big fan of hunting with a patched roundball. I just don't think that it does as good of a job as a heavy sabot/pistol bullet or a maxiball. I shot a doe with a roundball once and had a long, sparse bloodtrail. I eventually found the deer, but it was a long recovery. The ball was placed perfectly just behind the shoulder. It pierced both lungs and nicked the heart. I found the ball just under the skin on the far side of the carcass. With maxiballs and jacketed bullets, I have complete passthroughs.
On the other hand, I have had slightly more deer shot with heavy conicals travel a longer distance after hit. Maybe 20-25% of them have ran after the hit. Most have gone down within 50 yds but I have had several go near 100 yds, with one traveling over 200 yds. To be honest and fair, I hit her a bit high, from a tree stand and only clipped the top of one lung.
Bottom line is I believe soft lead roundballs are the most effective projectile that can used on deer, within 100 yds. Within that range, I would rate them higher in knockdown power than heavy lead conicals certainly no less. A heavy conical can certainly carry more energy down range but once it blows clear through the deer, any extra energy is gone, providing no benefit. A soft lead roundball is the shortest projectile you can use and will expand more, in ratio to it's length, than any projectile. Since it is lighter, it also is moving at a higher velocity, at shorter ranges, than a conical. This gives the best combination of expansion and velocity, IMO.