GaryO

Any of you folks been hunting for elk on fenced in ranches? Did it seems like fair chase to you? Sounds like South Africa. I have been there twice and hunted my fanny off for most of my game. I will admit we drove around the ranches, too. What say you? Thought I may harvest a cow with my daughter? Thanks...

Muley Hunter

You'll get opinions on both sides, and some opinions are pretty strong.

Personally, I only hunt public land.

GaryO

Pete,
With a dog that looks like yours, no one would let you on private land...

Topgun 3006

Not even going to comment on the question the OP asked because it's been beaten to death on this and every other hunting website, but the response to Pete about his poor old dog was too much, LOL!

GaryO

that pooch looks like it's been beaten to death, too. hee hee...

Muley Hunter

I thought the dog in my avatar was funny. He makes me chuckle everytime I see him. Of course it's not my dog.

This is my dog. he loves the mountains.

Topgun 3006

Well heck, I thought that was your pooch! I also get a chuckle every time I see those two big teeth, LOL!

homers brother

I don't consider situations where fences exist to keep the animals inside them as hunting in the same sense that I do a public-land hunt. Out of principle, I prefer not even thinking about paying cash for access, let alone cash to shoot a confined animal. But, I'm happy if I get skunked once in awhile, provided I enjoyed my time in the woods.

However, I'm not everyone else, and there are others who prefer a guarantee of some sort that they'll kill something, even to the point of paying for the opportunity and front-loading their odds of success. To each his own.

flags

To each his own but I'm not hunting anywhere that a fence impedes the animal's ability to move around at will. As always, feel free to disagree.

buckman11

this thread should be entilted: Fenced in shooting. it aint huntin if the animals are fed and behind an 8 ft fence.