Do outfitters have minimum caliber requirements?
#1
Fork Horn
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Northeast Texas
Posts: 442
Do outfitters have minimum caliber requirements?
I was talking to my Dad recently about following through on our dream to book an elk hunt.
I know someone locally who went on an elk hunt a few years ago and was made to carry a rifle of .30 caliber or greater. He has a .270 Win. that he uses for everything, and fully intended to on his elk hunt. He wound up buying a .300 WSM just for that hunt.
Has anyone run across outfitters that have a " nothing smaller than this caliber" rule for their clients?
I know someone locally who went on an elk hunt a few years ago and was made to carry a rifle of .30 caliber or greater. He has a .270 Win. that he uses for everything, and fully intended to on his elk hunt. He wound up buying a .300 WSM just for that hunt.
Has anyone run across outfitters that have a " nothing smaller than this caliber" rule for their clients?
#2
I was talking to my Dad recently about following through on our dream to book an elk hunt.
I know someone locally who went on an elk hunt a few years ago and was made to carry a rifle of .30 caliber or greater. He has a .270 Win. that he uses for everything, and fully intended to on his elk hunt. He wound up buying a .300 WSM just for that hunt.
Has anyone run across outfitters that have a " nothing smaller than this caliber" rule for their clients?
I know someone locally who went on an elk hunt a few years ago and was made to carry a rifle of .30 caliber or greater. He has a .270 Win. that he uses for everything, and fully intended to on his elk hunt. He wound up buying a .300 WSM just for that hunt.
Has anyone run across outfitters that have a " nothing smaller than this caliber" rule for their clients?
#3
I was talking to my Dad recently about following through on our dream to book an elk hunt.
I know someone locally who went on an elk hunt a few years ago and was made to carry a rifle of .30 caliber or greater. He has a .270 Win. that he uses for everything, and fully intended to on his elk hunt. He wound up buying a .300 WSM just for that hunt.
Has anyone run across outfitters that have a " nothing smaller than this caliber" rule for their clients?
I know someone locally who went on an elk hunt a few years ago and was made to carry a rifle of .30 caliber or greater. He has a .270 Win. that he uses for everything, and fully intended to on his elk hunt. He wound up buying a .300 WSM just for that hunt.
Has anyone run across outfitters that have a " nothing smaller than this caliber" rule for their clients?
That makes no sense on the outfitters part, I would take that to mean I could show up with a .32 special, 30-30 or some such, but not a 270 or a .25-06 which have killed many a elk...now don't anyone get yer panties all in a bunch I did not put down the .32 or the 30-30 both of those rounds have killed untold numbers of deer,elk and bear of all sizes, both of theses rounds are out and out deadly to game in the brush and close in...I was just trying to point out how silly the restriction sounded!!
#5
Fork Horn
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Northeast Texas
Posts: 442
I should have been more specific in my original post. While the outfitter did say ".30 caliber minimum", the understanding was .308/.30-06 and up. No .30-30's or such.
I know each state has their legal minimum calibers, but having never been on a guided hunt I didn't know if I should expect to hear the same as I begin to call around. We won't be able to book the hunt for 2-3 years, so I have time to buy something specific for elk or whatever else might be available.
I know each state has their legal minimum calibers, but having never been on a guided hunt I didn't know if I should expect to hear the same as I begin to call around. We won't be able to book the hunt for 2-3 years, so I have time to buy something specific for elk or whatever else might be available.
#7
Like I said it still makes NO sense.....the 270 surpasses the 308 at 500 yds and is more than equal to the 30.06 with a 150 gr bullet all of winchester manufature.......I have to agree with bigbulls, this outfitter is suckin wind up his butt and I would look else where........I can see a minimum cal for dangerous game but not elk!!
#9
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Jun 2008
Posts: 1,526
Like I said it still makes NO sense.....the 270 surpasses the 308 at 500 yds and is more than equal to the 30.06 with a 150 gr bullet all of winchester manufature.......I have to agree with bigbulls, this outfitter is suckin wind up his butt and I would look else where........I can see a minimum cal for dangerous game but not elk!!
Second, how many elk are shot at or beyond 500 yards every year? Not enough to warrant your 270 to 308 comparison. Although I do agree that a 270 is adequate for killing elk.
Third, and lastly, while the 308 is similar to the 30-06 it is not "more than equal" in any area to it.