Originally Posted by
finnbear
Like I said it still makes NO sense.....the 270 surpasses the 308 at 500 yds and is more than equal to the 30.06 with a 150 gr bullet all of winchester manufature.......I have to agree with bigbulls, this outfitter is suckin wind up his butt and I would look else where........I can see a minimum cal for dangerous game but not elk!!
First, I dont agree with an outfitter mandating a minimum caliber for elk, but it is his/her business and they can do as they see fit. The consumer on the other hand can do the same thing.
Second, how many elk are shot at or beyond 500 yards every year? Not enough to warrant your 270 to 308 comparison. Although I do agree that a 270 is adequate for killing elk.
Third, and lastly, while the 308 is similar to the 30-06 it is not "more than equal" in any area to it.