WNYhunter let me also say I am 100% in favor of the legality of coming to your place and me paying you $$$$$$$$$ to shoot one of your biggest tamest bull elk

just like if I went to a bison farm and shot one, or a cattle farm and shot a steer



but it aint hunting

New law proposed. Any canned hunts (AKA shooting livestock behind a fence) are legal as long as the antlers have been cut off ahead of time. The "sport" can only have the meat. Without the antlers there probably won't be much killing....
Seriously though, I hate to see any of it happening. The amount of money someone will spend for a large set of antlers is getting ridiculous. The only thing it leads to is keeping the common man out of the game. In the past hunting permission in the mid west could be granted with a handshake. Now it has to have several thousand greenbacks with it. The costs associated with hunting have gone up faster than the price of gasoline last summer with no end in sight. Biologically speaking, the spread of CWD, blue tongue, brucellosis and other cervid communicable diseases will limit the influx of these wild game farms soon enough in most states. If any area thinks they are immune to the spread they have their heads in the sand.

Stealthy, having spent more than two months in the field, huntingin Zimbabwe and Botswana, your scenario is one I feel I can answer with some experience. All of my African hunting has been from tent camps on completely wild and open concessions. Not only were there no fences, there weren't many roads where I've hunted, either. That said, I think that many African hunting operations where they have high fences are plenty fair chase. Most of the high fenced operations are in South Africa, from what I've learned, and most of those properties are thousands or tens of thousands of acres in size. I have no doubt that they can hunt in a fair chase manner on large properties that are fenced around the perimeter. The primary reason they fence their properties, from what I understand, is to keep the game on their property, and with many thousands of acres, the animals are easily able to avoid the hunters. I'd have no problem with hunting on many of those properties, though I've never done it. I would not be inclined to hunt on a property with high fences that was anything less than thousands of acres but probably never will as I really love the experience of tent camping in the wild where you have leopards and other creatures of the night come through camp while you're sleeping. At various times, we've had lions in camp (they ransacked our kitchen while we all huddled in our tents), leopard tracks around the campfire in the morning when we got up for a cup of tea before heading out; an elephant that blocked our path between sections of a camp one time; as well as having the heck scared out of us by a cape buffalo bull that we surprised as we waked through some brush just 50 yards from our tents one time. That's the Africa that I love, and why I've chosenhunts where I can tent camp in the wild.

stealthycatII, I agree with you all the way. It is not hunting, plain and simple. Mabey the bigger the area fenced (5000-10000 acres) the more real it seems but it is still a shoot not a hunt, you might just have to look a little longer but you know they are there.

Champlain Islander, now I think you are bringing your opinion into it. This is the USA, a legal activity is just that. You don't have to like it, but that is just the way it is. As far as the common man, hunting preserves aren't hurting us. Take a look around, it's called supply and demand. A rancher is going to get what he can as long as there are people willing to pay.

You are right I am bringing in my opinion. I never claimed anything else. Supply and demand hunting will always have its followers on both sides of that fence. Those looking at taking a shortcut at harvesting a game animal and those looking at profiting on the backs of people lacking sportsmanship. If it is a legal activity then both sides have every right to do what they want. In some places canned hunting is illegal. The reasons vary but most recent anti canned hunting laws were enacted to prevent the spread of disease to the wild animals. There have been many documented cases of initial CWD infections first appearing in a game farm then spreading to adjacent wild animals not inside the fence. That scenario ocurred 2 years ago in your state (I assume you are from NY) in Oneida County. I personally would't kill an animal in a canned hunting situation. Then again the actual killing of an animal isn't the necessaryend result of my hunts. I go for the chase and the chance at becoming one with nature not one with a fence. None of my hunts have been a failure. Sometimes I have been rewarded with game and other times all I have is the memory. I just saw in the daily rag that Vermont will conduct public hearings to decide how best to deal with the spread of canned hunting operations in this state. They are being proactive in an attempt to keep CWD out of here.

Champlain Islander,

I think we are alot alike. I enjoy hunting but the taking of an animal is just a bonus for. Cwd, yes we had a case here in NY. I believe it is all around, but being in less than 1% of the population makes it tough to find unless the animal is behind a fence. Do you know where CWD started and what it is?

CWD was first identified as a fatal wasting syndrome in captive mule deer in Colorado in the late 1960s and in the wild in 1981. It was recognized as a spongiform encephalopathy in 1978. It is similar to Mad cow" disease (bovine spongiform encephalopathy or BSE) or the human variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease. it is almost always fatal and until recently only showed up in the old hot areas of theRocky's and Canada. In the past 5 years it has moved to a few other states such as NY and Wisconsin where they tried to stop it by systematically killing all the deer within a 287 square mile radius. It didn’t stop the spread and when it shows up it is a game changer for both the F&W departments and the hunters. Once it shows it will always be there. I often hunt NY and since CWD showed it is illegal to bring a whole animal back to Vermont. If I get a deer there I have to butcher it there and can only bring deboned meat, cleaned skull cap and antlers back to Vermont. Since theinfection can be passed between animals, Vermontmade it illegal to bait deer to minimize the chances of anoutbreak from spreading. Making captive deer or elk ranches illegal will probably happen here as well.

Good luck on your elk hunt. i'm jealous, wish I was going with you. I have made that trip a few times and hopefully going next year. I love hunting in big sky country. nothing like it. Well, if you ever make down near buffalo and want to hunt for a weekend, let me know.

Thanks WNY. One of my best hunting buds actually lives in Filmore NY (south of Rochester). He has gone with us on 3 trips to Newfoundland and the past 2 years to Colorado. We are leaving Vt tomorrow at 4am and will be picking him up at about noon. Got to try and make it near the Indiana border on day 1 though so we will be moving.