If you guys or girls would rate lord of the Rings The Return of the king. What would your rating be on 1-10. I ask because I havent seen it yet.

5-the editors got really sloppy on catching all sorts of probs-ask me about it when you've seen it.

yah id give it about a 5 as well, not as good as the second one.

5?!?! Ya'll are nuts

9.5

PA, it wasnt nearly as good as the second or first ones were!especially when they brought the cave dweller people in

I havent seen it so dont say too much guys lol[]

Lord of the Rings: Return of the King was better than the second one. The first wasn't as good as the other ones. I would give it an 8 or a 9.5

i would give it a 9.5 because they missed a lot of important stuff

If you look at how TERRIBLE the editors did their job you would have to knock it down to a 6-7. Then plug into the equation the fact of how much was not really covered in The Return of the King and you would be forced to knock it down to a 5!

5??? I'd like to see you do a better job![8D] They couldn't cover a whole lot because those books are so long. If they did cover it all, you'd still give it a 5 because you'd be sore from sitting in the theater for 6 hours!