I agree, The deer on the left looks like it has dropped an antler. The one on the right looks like it could be a young deer or a doe comparing the size to the other. They both looks small, and still growing

I agree!!!

Just curious- do button bucks shed their nubs?

Yes they do shed their nubs. i found one one time believe it or not.

Deer 1 - What was that ?

Deer 2 - I duno .

Deer 1 - you think its one of those bugs that light up ?

Deer 2 - if it was it was a big sucker.

Deer 1 - it looks like them things that go on the shiny black dirt with the funny lines on it.

Deer 2 - yep it sure does you think it will run us over ?

Deer 1 - we aint on the black shiny dirt with them funny lines.

Deer 2 - oh yeah I sure am glad.

Deer 2 - I seen one hit by one of the big things that has a lot of wheels

Deer 1 - you mean the one that wiggles in the middle like a snake.

Deer 2 - I don't know what it was but poor wilbor sure was squished all over the black dirt.

Deer 1 - Well its about day time we better go before them two legged animals come around.

Deer 2 - I ques you are right see ya tomorrow night bye now.

Deer 1- Yeah see you tomorrow night bye.

I shot a button buck/ spike this year. Compared to my deer your deer appears to be a young buck that had some sort of a rack.
Chuck