RE: Lung Shot and Still survive????????
 

High and way back,, maybe a cut up diaphram but in no way a lung shot..

Personally I think alot of photoshop on that picture!

RE: Lung Shot and Still survive????????
 

I'd have to say that it would be very hard for a deer to survive a lung shot! With just one lung being hit, it may survive a little longer, but eventually, it is going to drown in its own blood!
As far as the buck picture, with all the photo editing programs these days, I'd have to see that deer or know the person that took the picture!
If its real, it does look like a steep angle, too far back!
The one thing that makes me think "phoney," is I don't think a buck with that kind of wound would be standing at a bait pile!

RE: Lung Shot and Still survive????????
 

I have to agree with jag. Aint no way a deer will survive a razor tip broad head to one lung. It will never stop bleeding. He will go farther, but he aint gonna make to the next night and sit and eat some corn. Uh uh. Got to be photo shop

RE: Lung Shot and Still survive????????
 

If you ask me i think that it will die eventually, sounds like you definitly hit a lung though, maybe just nicked it

RE: Lung Shot and Still survive????????
 

i have never personally hit only one lung on a deer. but i do know that deer have an amazing will to survive. i have seen deer spook up in front of me that have one, two, or even three legs broken from poor shots. its sad to see. but deer will keep going until they cant go anymore. anyone who has hit a deer good and tracked it forever will tell you the same thing.

RE: Lung Shot and Still survive????????
 

The first deer I shot was one lung and the arrow stopped in the heart. That sucker ran 400 yards! It did die though.

I agree, I don't see one surviving with punctured lung, but it does take a bit longer for them to die that way.

I'm suprised we don't have anyone here that is a vet and could answer it for sure. I know we have some doctors though.

Paul

RE: Lung Shot and Still survive????????
 

I am a physician, and yes an animal can survive very nicely with only one lung. A single lung shot will not be fatal unless a large enough blood vessle has been hit to cause a fatal hemmorhage or a tension pneumothorax develops.

RE: Lung Shot and Still survive????????
 

That pic is Photo shopped or the arrow is high and is lodged in the muscle of the back strap. If it was to hit a lung that arrow would be moving alot and slice up more and more of the lung with every step the deer took. Also if you want to say it is the shoulder, then the shaft would still be in the lungmoving with every step and prevent a clot from forming.That is either a missed lung and somehow lodged above or photo shopped. Any one who has shot and recovered a deer with an arrow that did not pass through knows how much damage they do as they run and walk. Missed lung or photo shopped, only two possibilities!

RE: Lung Shot and Still survive????????
 

I am a skeptic, so I automatically think this image was photoshoped.
It may be real, but I could not use it as a basis for this arguement until it was verified.

oh yeah, here is a picture of my cat :D

RE: Lung Shot and Still survive????????
 

that deer wasnt lung shot the lungs is a bit lower than that