Unlocked

Anyone have any ideas?

grinder67

I am certainly no expert by ant stretch of the imagination but I am going to guess the smaller one at 120-125 and the other at 130-135. But again just a guess

crokit

I believe it to be a stretch for either deer being 120 +

Oldtimr

Reducing deer to what they may score in B&C or P&Y is a sorry way to decide what you are going to kill. Killing a bigger buck than your buddy does not make you a better hunter, it makes you luckier than him on one occasion.

crokit

I'm pretty sure the original post wasn't referring to trying to decide which buck to kill based on score, unless assumptions are being made. I read the original post as asking " anyone have any idea on score."

Wisco94

Correct me if I'm wrong but I don't think that was the question... You're assuming that the only reason that person is going to shoot a deer is based on score. I don't shoot deer strictly based on score, but I do like to have an idea of what they'll score because it does play a part in whether or not I'll shoot them. Some guys hunt for antlers, don't think for a second however that means they respect the animals any less or don't take as much away from the hunt as a guy who doesn't. Get off your high horse. Also, in regards to the question I think the smaller of the two is around 120 and the other may be around 130. Both very nice deer!

dbllunged

both are between 110 and 120

WIbuckchaser

I'd guess the bigger one will be right around 118-120. I just guess. I have a ten on the wall that looks similar so that's how I judge it.

BigRidge

The big boy will push 120 the smaller 110