Originally Posted by
Oldtimr
Reducing deer to what they may score in B&C or P&Y is a sorry way to decide what you are going to kill. Killing a bigger buck than your buddy does not make you a better hunter, it makes you luckier than him on one occasion.
Correct me if I'm wrong but I don't think that was the question... You're assuming that the only reason that person is going to shoot a deer is based on score. I don't shoot deer strictly based on score, but I do like to have an idea of what they'll score because it does play a part in whether or not I'll shoot them. Some guys hunt for antlers, don't think for a second however that means they respect the animals any less or don't take as much away from the hunt as a guy who doesn't. Get off your high horse. Also, in regards to the question I think the smaller of the two is around 120 and the other may be around 130. Both very nice deer!