RE: PA antler restriction
 

LOL it wouldnt stand for Apollo Ridge! I'm on the other side of the river.
Kiski country!
My dad lives near saltsburg and I do a bit of hunting out that way myself and I fish the Conemaugh a bit. No fish there though;)especially in the lake;)

RE: PA antler restriction
 

Here is the second reason he gave for implementing ARs.


So the first two reasons have nothing to do with improving the breeding ecology, recruitment ,productivity or rack size!!!

RE: PA antler restriction
 

We need more BBR's(bluebird restrictions) in here.;)

RE: PA antler restriction
 

Kinda like that booger you just cant seem to flick away;)

RE: PA antler restriction
 

Is that because the AR supporters can't come up with anything to justify implementing ARs in PA?

here's Kroll's third and most interesting reason for ARs.
So Kroll's answer to over population is to save more bucks. Or, maybe he is saying the reason for implementing ARs is to get gullible hunters to shoot more doe,like Alt was successful at doing just that.

RE: PA antler restriction
 

Once again, you use only the little slices that suit you. Why not type or scan in the whole article?

Oh, I know, that would fail to support your position!

FLICK.....still here....FLICK.......stil here.....FLICK... still here

RE: PA antler restriction
 

You were the first one to raise the issue of Dr. Kroll's article and claimed that he pointed out the flaws in the Miss. study. As yet you have provided nothing valid,from the article to support your position. It would be a copyright violation to post the entire article, but you are free to provide quotes to support your position, if you can find one.

Dr. Krolls article does nothing to refute the findings of Dr. DEmarais studies in Miss. and it does nothing to support a need for ARs in PA.

RE: PA antler restriction
 

FLICK!!!

RE: PA antler restriction
 

I understand your frustration. You opened a can of worms for AR supporters with that article by Kroll and now you can't find anything to defend it. Before , I thought kroll did some good research, but since he now shows he doesn't understand the concept of high grading, I wonder how much he really knows about the effects of ARs.

RE: PA antler restriction
 

And when can we expect to see your research and conclusions in print? Other than in the USP magazine that is.