I am not holding my breath on this one

Oldelk, start it off, what's your choice and why do you think it's better.

Well first off all the other forums are more focused. Big game hunting is discussed in the big game forum ..guns are discussed here even though lots of times scopes are mentioned as well. Would be an easier place to search on specific scopes other then tying up resources doing a search in the subject and body of a post's dating back a year looking for feedback on a specific scope.

Would be another cool place to hang out!

You're right, we do. Right now, scope posts appear in Guns, Firearm Reviews, and Hunting Gear. Since it doesn't seem that everyone will agree on where to post scope topics, a scope forum is certainly called for. Heck, it could be called "Optics" to include bino's and spotting scopes, even sun glasses (see Off Season right now.)