What would it be? (Chuck we all know it would be a white rooster tail for you!)

I of course would fish my frog.

a Red and silver Gotcha.

A Spinnerbait, have caught everything under the sun of them that I've fished for

You are correct Indy.

10" Zoom black worm, fished weightless.

Hair jig....Brown... If I had only ONE weight it would be 1/8 oz, despite the fact that I fish 1/16 oz about 90% of the time...

I would preffer a streamer, but that's a fly, so I would use a flat fish. I have a few in my tackle box that I haven't used in a long time. I guess I will need to give them a try.

I would have to go with Chuck on this one. I have caught smallies, walleye, white bass, pike, musky, crappie and even catfish with them!

If I could not pick the time of year and I had to pick a lure that works year round. I would def. choose a white spinnerbait.

If I was stuck on an island with one lure I would go with #15 in line as above with the balck stripe OR a floating Rapala OR a silver Johnson spoon - Tough One