140 , is that a PA deer? i see ur a fellow pennsylvanian , if so , can i hunt wiht yins?

I did not scroll down the page to look at any other guesses but I will go with 174?

DoubleLung, yep thats a Pa deer...He was killed in Rifle season during 2003, in York County.

When you do post it, post the gross and net scores if you don't mind.

BTW the other 9 point on the right ain't to shabby either Whats the story on that one?

Here is another for you guys to guess on. Whats he score? If you know from a past post please do not reply.

164

I'm gonna guess in the mid to high 120's also. I have seen a 147" buck, and it was large (to me). I sort of gave up hope of ever shooting a P&Y buck after seeing it, because I had never seen anywhere near that big of a deer before.

What saddens me the most about this post and the post that originated all of this, is that it is starting to prove Atlasman's post "The writing on the wall" to be correct.

Relax, guys. It's for fun.

Wish we had a better pic of him,but if i had to guess a score then i'd say 134 .They are both nice deer,congrats to your dad.
Now on a side note who is complaining about the scores,and who are these so called experts.Comeon jerry,we are trying to prove a point here arent we

for buckeyes deer im goin to say around the high 130's low 140's

Bw and Mathews, you guys are no where near close yet. Keep trying[8D]

Here is another view. There is no arm stretching going on here either