For anybody who think people lie about having a big buck!!!
#1
Thread Starter
Typical Buck
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 827
Likes: 0
From: Dover, Ohio. Tuscarawas county.
That big buck I have been talking about is real!!! One time my dad and I were hunting. I was with him and he actually shot him and we tracked him and the blood trail ran out. We gave up and a week later my dad shot a 8-point buck (with a split brow-tine) and while he was tracking him, my dad jumped up the monster buck and he knew it was the same buck because we know what the rack looked like by heart. By the way my dad found the 8-point buck. We also have a couple bucks that would score over 150. We also have 2 bucks that would score over or about 200. One we think is a typical. We are not going to sell any of the deer. We also hunt where there is no fences around (no lie). I do not like people making fun of a monster buck that scores about or over 300 when they have never seen him with their own eyes like my dad and I have!
#3
Fork Horn
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 443
Likes: 0
From: NY! the middle part
OK let me put this in a light you can realate to. We are not the jealousy driven people you think we are. Many people here understand the statistical improbability that are the conditions you are describing. Forgive us for being cynical, but the fact of the matter is there are very very very few tracts of land that are home to 150 , 200 and even a 300 class buck at all much less at the same time and in multiple occurances.
The thing is this is old hat to alot of us guys here and the discussion you started really has no merit without some sort of proof. by no means are we calling you a liar. We are merely being realists. PLease take this in only a positive way. THis is not an insult or meant to hurt feelings, it is simply an explination of where the majority of this board is coming from when we say, "i doubt it". I hope we are wrong. I also hope that you get a chance to harvest this animal in a fair chase hunt. I think i speak for the majority when i say, hunt hard and i will be nothing but happy for you if you get a chance at one of those numerous monsters you have.
The thing is this is old hat to alot of us guys here and the discussion you started really has no merit without some sort of proof. by no means are we calling you a liar. We are merely being realists. PLease take this in only a positive way. THis is not an insult or meant to hurt feelings, it is simply an explination of where the majority of this board is coming from when we say, "i doubt it". I hope we are wrong. I also hope that you get a chance to harvest this animal in a fair chase hunt. I think i speak for the majority when i say, hunt hard and i will be nothing but happy for you if you get a chance at one of those numerous monsters you have.
#6
Typical Buck
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 549
Likes: 0
From:
Give me a sometime to locate some pics of a 198 class whitetail hanging on my wall and see how it compares to the 300 class. I don't have a digital camera so I have to find those pics. A 200 class buck is a monster. This one has 19points and has a total spread of 24". I'm not trying to be disrespectful but it takes one heck of a deer to go 200.
#7
Deer Destroyer........I don't want to discourage a young hunter from participating on the boards, and I won't. I just ask that you use a little caution in your posting, maybe read a while and see how things work around here, or better yet help your fellow young hunters in the "Young hunters" forum. You seem to be a "seasoned" hunter for 15 and those other kids might benefit from your experiences.
Remember, there are no pictures and line showing your age on this forum. If you post with adults, most likely they will assume you are an adult and treat you as such.
Please be careful how you use the forums, and read the posting rules.
Do have fun, and I hope you learn alot here.....and welcome.
Remember, there are no pictures and line showing your age on this forum. If you post with adults, most likely they will assume you are an adult and treat you as such.

Please be careful how you use the forums, and read the posting rules.
Do have fun, and I hope you learn alot here.....and welcome.
#8
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 2,062
Likes: 0
From: CWD Central, WI.
I'm from tusc. county.
Best place to hunt. Most deer killed in my county than any other in Ohio!!!!
Best place to hunt. Most deer killed in my county than any other in Ohio!!!!
#9
Giant Nontypical
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 9,175
Likes: 0
Deer Destroyer, everybody knows people LIE LIKE DOGS when it comes to hunting and fishing stories. The field rat they shot last year becomes a monster elk, real easy. 
I hope you do have the deer you claim you've got. But if you do, you're an idjit for posting about it on a public forum. If someone who knows you lets the word out about where your property is, you'll be overrun with trespassers. You keep things like that SECRET until you have the hero pictures to post.

I hope you do have the deer you claim you've got. But if you do, you're an idjit for posting about it on a public forum. If someone who knows you lets the word out about where your property is, you'll be overrun with trespassers. You keep things like that SECRET until you have the hero pictures to post.
#10
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 1,251
Likes: 0
From: crawfordville florida USA
We like pictures. Go over to Walmart and get a couple trail cameras.
Nobody here believed my 3 year old killed a nice 8 pt with his bow but whos eating crow now?!?
Nobody here believed my 3 year old killed a nice 8 pt with his bow but whos eating crow now?!?



]