need helping choosing broadhead.
#33
Spike
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location:
Posts: 35

I shot rage two blade chisel tip last year. After loosing a monster 8pt in Illinois and several other deer in Ga and Fl, I decided to go back to the trusty thunderhead. I have more than 20 rages that are bent in the ferrel area. When this happens the insert is also bent and the arrow shaft splits. First 8pt this year I lost due to not getting a pass thru. NO BLOOD anywhere and I shot the deer about 6 ft from my tree. Came home and purchased a 6pk of TH. This past weekend I shot another 8pt thru both shoulders with complete pass thru and into the dirt. He went 30 yards. I shoot and believe different than most hunters with arrow weight and speed. I want Lite and fast arrows for flatter trajectory. With the rages the arrow only goes in about a third to half of its length. Please don't say my arrows are too lite as I regularly get pass thru on 200# large boar hogs shooting both shoulders with the thunderheads. Oh fwiw, my bow shoots field pts, rages and thunderheads the same(poi).
Last edited by Stickthrower; 09-30-2013 at 04:48 PM.
#34
Spike
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 13

I personally dislike mechanical heads. I bought mechanicals once and after a few afternoons of shooting them I decided then and there that they are not for me. It once was an issue that some outfitters were banning use of mechanicals heads on their hunts. I'm not sure of this is still the case. But hearing that and then having my own issues with them sealed the deal for me.
I've been shooting Muzzy 3-blade 100g heads for years and have zero complaints about the performance of the head. I did shoot thunderheads at first but I didn't like how it needed a ring and then had to be screwed onto the shaft to keep the head together. Muzzy's lock in place with the tip and become one piece.
I've been shooting Muzzy 3-blade 100g heads for years and have zero complaints about the performance of the head. I did shoot thunderheads at first but I didn't like how it needed a ring and then had to be screwed onto the shaft to keep the head together. Muzzy's lock in place with the tip and become one piece.
#35
Fork Horn
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Missouri
Posts: 156

I shot rage two blade chisel tip last year. After loosing a monster 8pt in Illinois and several other deer in Ga and Fl, I decided to go back to the trusty thunderhead. I have more than 20 rages that are bent in the ferrel area. When this happens the insert is also bent and the arrow shaft splits. First 8pt this year I lost due to not getting a pass thru. NO BLOOD anywhere and I shot the deer about 6 ft from my tree. Came home and purchased a 6pk of TH. This past weekend I shot another 8pt thru both shoulders with complete pass thru and into the dirt. He went 30 yards. I shoot and believe different than most hunters with arrow weight and speed. I want Lite and fast arrows for flatter trajectory. With the rages the arrow only goes in about a third to half of its length. Please don't say my arrows are too lite as I regularly get pass thru on 200# large boar hogs shooting both shoulders with the thunderheads. Oh fwiw, my bow shoots field pts, rages and thunderheads the same(poi).
Our lease no longer permits Rage as many other hunters were having similar problems. Our wounded deer have gone down drastically on our lease.
#39
Fork Horn
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Missouri
Posts: 156

They will do great on soft tissue I would never want one on my arrow when shooting through anything else. Most of the time if not all the time lost deer are poor shot placement but I want a head that gives me the best opportunity at recovering my game when things don't go perfectly and RAGE is not that head.
#40
Spike
Join Date: Oct 2013
Posts: 17

IMO Muzzy is the best out there for fixed blade. they fly great they are very strong i have never broke one. you can replace the blades after the shot, and they penatrate like crazy.
for mechanicals i would say ulmer edge are the best for sure. they are sharpend on opposite sides on both ends so they cut on a spyral going in and out. they penatrate surprisingly well for mechanical, and are very strong, also the blades pivot around bones so your arrow is not slowed down and penatrates very well. (they will be in my quiver this hunting season)
for mechanicals i would say ulmer edge are the best for sure. they are sharpend on opposite sides on both ends so they cut on a spyral going in and out. they penatrate surprisingly well for mechanical, and are very strong, also the blades pivot around bones so your arrow is not slowed down and penatrates very well. (they will be in my quiver this hunting season)