deer and smells
#1
Typical Buck
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: St. Louis, MO
Posts: 716
deer and smells
I have a question. With hunting scent business probably reaching the " multi-million dollar industry" title this has come to my mind recently. If deer can so easily scent us humans (cause we smell or cause our clothes smell or whatever) how did the native americans do it? They were exteremely proficient at what they did. Depending on their area many even lived off of it. So what was their secret? Less clothes less smell? They clothed in Animal pelt anyway so it masked human smell? Their food had less ' toxins' in it so therefore the smelled less that we? Smell is less of a variable than we think?
What' s your opinion?
What' s your opinion?
#2
RE: deer and smells
if you want deer not be scared of your scent, all you have to do is stop eating meat during hunting season. Dont get me wrong, I dont eat like a rabbit during the season, but I do not eat meat. I eat thing' s like pizza, spagetti, lasagna, and fish. A deer' s awesome sense of smell doesnt determine the difference between, rabbit, coyote, cow or human, what they do is determine between, meat eater and non meat eater. The toxin' s in the food' s we eat will not alarm deer, just like the smell of automobiles and mack truck' s do not alarm deer when their standing 2 ft. of a major highway feeding. Pike
#3
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: East Yapank NY USA
Posts: 3,457
RE: deer and smells
if you want deer not be scared of your scent, all you have to do is stop eating meat during hunting season. Dont get me wrong, I dont eat like a rabbit during the season, but I do not eat meat. I eat thing' s like pizza, spagetti, lasagna, and fish. A deer' s awesome sense of smell doesnt determine the difference between, rabbit, coyote, cow or human, what they do is determine between, meat eater and non meat eater. The toxin' s in the food' s we eat will not alarm deer, just like the smell of automobiles and mack truck' s do not alarm deer when their standing 2 ft. of a major highway feeding. Pike
I WISH, If I thought for one second that deer would not be scared of my scent if I did not eat meat, I would eat carrots 365 days a year - and that’s the truth.
It just isn’t so. People smell like people - can' t change that by eating veggies. There is allot more to our smell than just the food we eat. Deer are capable of telling individual deer apart by just there smell - do you really think a vegetarian smells just like a cow to them.
And besides - everything you stated you eat has eggs in it - that is meat, and fish are eaten by many predators - bears included.
Believe me they know exactly what they are smelling - rabbit - fox -raccoon- humans. There sense of smell is there #1 defense by far and it is awesome and always correct.
You HAVE TOPLAY THE WIND - be it after burgers or blueberries
And the reason deer are not scared of truck fumes along a highway is because they expect to smell those fumes along a highway. Not only can they decipher what they smell they know were the smell belongs and where it doesn' t. Take that same truck fume and put it in their beds or away from the highway and they WILL know something is not right.
#4
RE: deer and smells
Rack attack, First let me stay, I still play the wind, and take every other scent precaution I can, alway' s have, but you mock what you dont understand, and that is fine, the truth is that your body produces a different scent when you eat meat then when you dont . The difference in scent is caused by bacteria, This bacteria isnt present with non meater' s. Egg' s have nothing to do with it either, because I am talking about Red Meat. Pike
#5
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Wisconsin
Posts: 3,903
RE: deer and smells
how did the native americans do it? They were exteremely proficient at what they did.
#6
RE: deer and smells
Bowfantic, I think I also read somewhere, that in many tribes, they would stop having relations with the opposite sex for a cetain time period before the hunt. Another thing the indian' s did and I do on occassion, when im camping and dont have the use of a shower is to rub the chared coal from the camp fire to mask my scent. Pike