I have to admit they are very similar. I understand your argument about the G2's but I still do not think that can account for the large apparent difference - on his left side especially. The Left G2 and G3s on the 7/20 pic are *aproximately* the same length. There is no way the buck in the 7/26 pic has left G2 & G3s of the same length(assuming the tines are parallel as would be the case depicted by the other pic)....but of course, thats just my opinion.

not the same buck, looks to me like the brow tines are different... the left buck the browtine goes in and the right buck one goes out... def. nice deer tho! i'll help take him for you..

i think it is 2 different deer judging by the G2s...

Same buck for sure. The angle make some things look different, but its the same deer unless you have two deer running around with the exact same body size and antler characteristics.

What would you know about 10-pointers?[8D]

Nothing!

I think it is the same deer.

I hope those of you who think it's not the same buck are right!

FWIW, from the folks who have voted, 41% feel that there's a 75% or better
chance that it's the same buck. Whereas, 41% feel that there's a 25% or worse
chance that it's the same buck. With 15% of the respondents calling it a 50/50 toss up.

That's what I call a split decision !! This website was definitely the most heavily favored
of it not being the same buck (of the 3 websites I put this poll on, with Mathews & ArcheryTalk
being the other two).

Any one else want to vote & break the virtual tie?

Rob

bump...........

hes the same buck its just the angle that makes it look like the g2 is different the body and the rack size look exactly the same.