The Amish
05-15-2008, 05:35 PM
#1
Spike
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Pittsburgh, Pa
Posts: 24
The Amish
In my little area of southwest pa, the Amish are quite proflific here. They also own a great majority of the farmland. Anyone have any experience asking The Amish for permission to hunt their lands? I have made some attempts at building some relationships but alwayswimp out when it comes down to the money question. For some odd reason I find them to be a very imtimidating bunch..sideburns and all!
Anyone ever make an attempt at this?
Anyone ever make an attempt at this?
05-15-2008, 06:22 PM
#3
Typical Buck
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Mifflin Co. Pa
Posts: 829
RE: The Amish
I grew up with amish neighbors and never had a problem hunting their land. I know of a Mennonite family that has sweet land but wont post it due to religious reasons (atleast thats what i was told as to why the wont post it, not sure if its true). Ask away, the worst they can say is "no".
05-15-2008, 06:33 PM
#4
Typical Buck
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Florida & PA
Posts: 570
RE: The Amish
The amish that I hunt around are notorious for killing deer out of season. At least we think it is them. We've found multiple carcasses near the line of their property. I think they get pissed off when the deer are in their crops. They always have been great about letting us hunt their property though.
05-15-2008, 06:35 PM
#5
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Georgia
Posts: 759
RE: The Amish
ORIGINAL: bmb2759
In my little area of southwest pa, the Amish are quite proflific here. They also own a great majority of the farmland. Anyone have any experience asking The Amish for permission to hunt their lands? I have made some attempts at building some relationships but alwayswimp out when it comes down to the money question. For some odd reason I find them to be a very imtimidating bunch..sideburns and all!
Anyone ever make an attempt at this?
In my little area of southwest pa, the Amish are quite proflific here. They also own a great majority of the farmland. Anyone have any experience asking The Amish for permission to hunt their lands? I have made some attempts at building some relationships but alwayswimp out when it comes down to the money question. For some odd reason I find them to be a very imtimidating bunch..sideburns and all!
Anyone ever make an attempt at this?
05-15-2008, 06:43 PM
#7
Typical Buck
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Streamwood,Illinois
Posts: 782
RE: The Amish
My friend hunts amish land in southern Illinois.He hauls grain in exchange for rights to hunt on his land.He has shot huge deer there the only problem is you cant hunt sundays and after the amish are done driving deer and shooting everything that moves the deer are scarce.
05-15-2008, 06:45 PM
#8
Typical Buck
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Florida & PA
Posts: 570
RE: The Amish
ORIGINAL: DropTine249
Isnt that called depredation ? and isnt it legal ?
Its legal here in NJ. Roughly 20years ago NJ adopted depredation. In fact, if you have crop on your property that nets $500 or more in profit, you qualify for a depredation or "black tag" permit, as long as your shooters posess a NJ Firearms Purchasers Identification Card. A F&W officer will come and inspect your property to deem it safe or unsafe to perform depredation.
Back to the subject.....why not just ask ?
You know them, they know you !! Im sure they dont want deer eating all of their crop...So, you need to munipulate the conversation, subconciously. Engage the farmer in conversation and before you "pop the question", lead the conversation in a direction that will make it as if YOU are doing HIM a favor by TELLING him that you will come hunt the deer. Say, hey Amish farmer man, give me a realistic number of deer that you would like taken out during the year.
Do not start by mentioning QDM. Do NOT offer money until someone asks.
Good luck on your endevor. If you wont ask, Ill come ask for you
I think they get pissed off when the deer are in their crops
Its legal here in NJ. Roughly 20years ago NJ adopted depredation. In fact, if you have crop on your property that nets $500 or more in profit, you qualify for a depredation or "black tag" permit, as long as your shooters posess a NJ Firearms Purchasers Identification Card. A F&W officer will come and inspect your property to deem it safe or unsafe to perform depredation.
Back to the subject.....why not just ask ?
You know them, they know you !! Im sure they dont want deer eating all of their crop...So, you need to munipulate the conversation, subconciously. Engage the farmer in conversation and before you "pop the question", lead the conversation in a direction that will make it as if YOU are doing HIM a favor by TELLING him that you will come hunt the deer. Say, hey Amish farmer man, give me a realistic number of deer that you would like taken out during the year.
Do not start by mentioning QDM. Do NOT offer money until someone asks.
Good luck on your endevor. If you wont ask, Ill come ask for you
05-15-2008, 06:45 PM
#9
Giant Nontypical
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Mont County, Pa
Posts: 7,368
RE: The Amish
Get some balls and just askthem. They're usually pretty fair from what I have heard. Like someone already said, the worst they can do is say no. Then you'll justhave to trespass. JK
05-15-2008, 07:21 PM
#10
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 2,193
RE: The Amish
yEAH...i HAD TO GIVE UP MY BEST OSAGE STICK AND FLINT WITH SINEW WRAPPED CEDAR...
KIDDING..I NEVER ASKED....BUT THEY ARE HEAVY IN UBLY MICHIGAN WHERE I HUNT IN THE THUMB....
SOMEDAYS I WISHED I WAS AMISH....I THINK I WOULD BE MORE AT PEACE AND LESS STRESSED....IT DOESN'T TAKE MUCH TO BE HAPPY....ALL THE MONEY IN THE WORLD WILL NOT REPLACE HEALTH AND PEACE OF MIND....I LOVE IT WHEN I SEE THEM AT CABELAS BUYING 3 BLADE EXPANDABLES.....
KIDDING..I NEVER ASKED....BUT THEY ARE HEAVY IN UBLY MICHIGAN WHERE I HUNT IN THE THUMB....
SOMEDAYS I WISHED I WAS AMISH....I THINK I WOULD BE MORE AT PEACE AND LESS STRESSED....IT DOESN'T TAKE MUCH TO BE HAPPY....ALL THE MONEY IN THE WORLD WILL NOT REPLACE HEALTH AND PEACE OF MIND....I LOVE IT WHEN I SEE THEM AT CABELAS BUYING 3 BLADE EXPANDABLES.....