HuntingNet.com Forums

HuntingNet.com Forums (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/)
-   Bowhunting (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/bowhunting-18/)
-   -   G5 Meta peep problem...... (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/bowhunting/226801-g5-meta-peep-problem.html)

buckeye 01-11-2008 08:37 PM

G5 Meta peep problem......
 

Have youguys noticed if your G5 meta peeps are "oblonging" out? My 1/4 inch hunter isn't round anymore..... More of an elliptical shape..... [/align]

Rob/PA Bowyer 01-11-2008 08:40 PM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
I only have two right now Scott. I put them on my General and Marquis. It's the first ones I've owned and I don't notice anything yet but they are fairly new. I have however heard of this before.



jmbuckhunter 01-11-2008 08:43 PM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
When they took mine off to put on my Verifier, the guy told me it wasn't round any more. I took a look and sure nuff I could tell it was oblong too. He sais the guy that tied it in had too much pressure on it. He should have had the ties farther from the peep.

I have heard others complain about this also.

buckeye 01-11-2008 08:49 PM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
Huh.... I have never heard anyone mention this before.... [&:]

Not cool..... I own about $60 worth of these things........

jmbuckhunter 01-11-2008 08:54 PM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
It has been mentioned on here before. But I had also heard they had fixed the problem. I guess not!!

gzg38b 01-11-2008 09:05 PM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 

ORIGINAL: jmbuckhunter

It has been mentioned on here before. But I had also heard they had fixed the problem. I guess not!!
G5 made the peeps stronger last year in response to these complaints. You may have got an old one. I've read in numerous places that the cause of the problem was operator error - people tying them in too close to the peep putting too much pressure on the peep.

I've never had this problem with mine. I tie it about 3/4" above and below.

buckeye 01-11-2008 09:08 PM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 

ORIGINAL: gzg38b


ORIGINAL: jmbuckhunter

It has been mentioned on here before. But I had also heard they had fixed the problem. I guess not!!
G5 made the peeps stronger last year in response to these complaints. You may have got an old one. I've read in numerous places that the cause of the problem was operator error - people tying them in too close to the peep putting too much pressure on the peep.

I've never had this problem with mine. I tie it about 3/4" above and below.
I don't even tie my peep in in that fashion... So that is not why mine has done it.....There is next to no pressure on my peep from serving it in..... [&:]

Back 40 Tree Rat 01-11-2008 09:11 PM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
How could this happen? They are made out of magnesium(spelling?) & that stuff breaks not bends.

ArrowMike 01-12-2008 12:15 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 

ORIGINAL: buckeye


ORIGINAL: gzg38b


ORIGINAL: jmbuckhunter

It has been mentioned on here before. But I had also heard they had fixed the problem. I guess not!!
G5 made the peeps stronger last year in response to these complaints. You may have got an old one. I've read in numerous places that the cause of the problem was operator error - people tying them in too close to the peep putting too much pressure on the peep.

I've never had this problem with mine. I tie it about 3/4" above and below.
I don't even tie my peep in in that fashion... So that is not why mine has done it.....There is next to no pressure on my peep from serving it in..... [&:]
Yes, they did have a problem with them about a year ago. I know that they changed them to fix it. Call them and see if they will replace them for you.

Cougar Mag 01-12-2008 01:35 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
Do they even still make them? Just went to their site and don't see them listed anywhere.

atlasman 01-12-2008 06:12 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
My shop wouldn't even sell or install them due to all the problems they had with this........they showed me a couple that actually had stress cracks because they were so out of shape.

I have a couple and even had one in my Equalizer with no problems but I didn't own it long enough to know for sure. I think this happens over time and is probably related to how much you shoot as well.



Send 'em back if you can.

GMMAT 01-12-2008 06:24 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
I don't know when they started having problems with them......but I ordered the first one my shop had ever put in......in December of '06. I had it taken out of my string, this week, when I had the SAP hooded peep with the verifier installed.

I just went downstairs and got the G5.....and mine is still round.....w/ no cracks.

Like my wife said....."If I sit here and look at it long enough.....I can probably be convinced its not round", though:D. I trust you guys, implicitly, about this. Mine's just not our of round.

Interesting....

buckeye 01-12-2008 06:38 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
I will send them an email and see what they say....

Out of the 6 I own only my 1/4 inch hunter peep shows this damage. The 1/8's and 3/16's peeps all look fine.




Arthur P 01-12-2008 06:40 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
I'm wondering what arrow weights you guys are using? Grains per pound of draw weight?

I've been shooting with a Meta peepat 7 gpp on a Bear TRX 36 at 65 lbsfor over a year and haven't experienced any egging.

buckeye 01-12-2008 06:44 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 

ORIGINAL: Arthur P

I'm wondering what arrow weights you guys are using? Grains per pound of draw weight?

I've been shooting with a Meta peepat 7 gpp on a Bear TRX 36 at 65 lbsfor over a year and haven't experienced any egging.
395 grains at 70 pounds.

GMMAT 01-12-2008 06:45 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
Do they make one bigger than 1/4"? I think I have the biggest one they make.....but I don't know.

buckeye 01-12-2008 06:46 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 

ORIGINAL: GMMAT

Do they make one bigger than 1/4"? I think I have the biggest one they make.....but I don't know.
Yes, 5/16's. It came out this year I believe.

GMMAT 01-12-2008 06:51 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
I'm trying to think.....but I'm pretty sure mine was installed when I bought my bow. If I'm not mistaken......mine might be 5/16", then (I know I ordered the biggest one they had).

Neither here nor there, though.....just wondering. I'm going to shoot some 3D at my shop @ 10:00. I'll ask them if they've heard any rumblings about this.

Thanks, Scott.

Matt/TN 01-12-2008 06:53 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
I honestly think it has something to do with the fact that Magnesium is not as strong and durable as say an aluminum Tru-Peep.


Also I think on 70lbs that string is "pinching" in on them pretty hard and over time it can happen.

GMMAT 01-12-2008 06:57 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
I was shooting 437gr @ 66#'s (Hunting) ......and 362gr @ 66#'s (target).

peakrut 01-12-2008 07:07 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
Is this a peep without a tube? If so any probs? I am thinking about going to a tubeless peep

bloodcrick 01-12-2008 07:07 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
Scott
Got a question for ya. What is the prefered hole size for 3-d in the meta peep ? I was going to get one for that and probable 1/4" for hunting. im ready to get away from the peep with the surgical tube.

buckeye 01-12-2008 07:11 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 

ORIGINAL: bloodcreek

Scott
Got a question for ya. What is the prefered hole size for 3-d in the meta peep ? I was going to get one for that and probable 1/4" for hunting. im ready to get away from the peep with the surgical tube.
I personally like a 3/16's for any sort of target venue. With the 1/8 I loose to much clarity and things become blurry to my eye thru it.


Is this a peep without a tube? If so any probs? I am thinking about going to a tubeless peep
Yes, it is tubeless.

peakrut 01-12-2008 07:13 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
Will I gain a few FPS without the tube? Thanks for the help btw.

I just looked it up on basspro.com and this has my name on it.

Arthur P 01-12-2008 07:16 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
Mine's 1/4" and not egged. It's the large sizes I'd think would be more susceptable to the problem.

Frankly, I suspect a relationship between egging and arrow weight in grains per pound. The lighter you go on arrow weight, the closer you get to a dry fire. Everyone knows that the first thing to get broken or lost on a dry fire is the peep sight because it's the first thing besides the string to take the full blast of that unexpended energy.

I'm at 7 gpp with no egging. Buckeye has egging at 5.6 gpp. It'd be nice for everyone who's having trouble with this problem to list their gpp and peep size. Might give G5's people some idea how much stronger they have to make their product. And give you something more constructive to do than just gripe about it. ;)

GMMAT 01-12-2008 07:16 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
Hey Scott.....

Wouldn't it matter HOW you shoot (RE: peep size for 3D)? For instance.....I shoot with both eyes open.....and I like to line up my peep with my sight housing. If others did this....wouldn't the size of their sight housing dictate the peep size?

Just asking......

Matt/TN 01-12-2008 07:25 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
I hunt with a 3/16" and shoot 3d/target with an 1/8th. When I move to a 1/16th peep, everything is just way to blurry.

GMMAT 01-12-2008 07:30 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
1/16" peep?

Are you serious? They make one this size? I can't imagine.[&:]

buckeye 01-12-2008 07:37 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 

ORIGINAL: FRALEY

Will I gain a few FPS without the tube? Thanks for the help btw.

I just looked it up on basspro.com and this has my name on it.
Yes, and your bow will be more quiet on the shot.


Hey Scott.....

Wouldn't it matter HOW you shoot (RE: peep size for 3D)? For instance.....I shoot with both eyes open.....and I like to line up my peep with my sight housing. If others did this....wouldn't the size of their sight housing dictate the peep size?

Just asking......

Yes, in some instances..... It might matter but in my case, it doesn't as my preferred 3/16's is a nice mate with my CopperJohn comp sight with the dovetail maxed out. I on the other hand shoot target with one eye closed.


Mine's 1/4" and not egged. It's the large sizes I'd think would be more susceptible to the problem.

Frankly, I suspect a relationship between egging and arrow weight in grains per pound. The lighter you go on arrow weight, the closer you get to a dry fire. Everyone knows that the first thing to get broken or lost on a dry fire is the peep sight because it's the first thing besides the string to take the full blast of that unexpended energy.

I'm at 7 gpp with no egging. Buckeye has egging at 5.6 gpp. It'd be nice for everyone who's having trouble with this problem to list their gpp and peep size. Might give G5's people some idea how much stronger they have to make their product. And give you something more constructive to do than just gripe about it. ;)

I agree it would be the larger sizes that would be more susceptible to "egging".

And uhhhh..... almost 400 grains is no where near close to a dryfire :eek::DBust out the Lincoln logs Arthur is in the house!

Also, I am not gripping, if anyone is it is you with others peoples choice of arrows ;)


[/align]

GMMAT 01-12-2008 07:41 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
Thanks, Scott. Sorry if it was O/T.

Interesting how others do it.

whitetailbowhunter 01-12-2008 08:01 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 


ORIGINAL: Cougar Mag

Do they even still make them? Just went to their site and don't see them listed anywhere.
Here you go! http://www.g5outdoors.com/#sec_metaline

Arthur P 01-12-2008 08:08 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 

And uhhhh..... almost 400 grains is now here near close to a dryfire Bust out the Lincoln logs Arthur is in the house!

Also, I am not gripping, if anyone is it is you with others peoples choice of arrows
No gripe from here because I don't have the problem! LOL

400 grains is closer to a dry fire than 500. That's all I'm sayin'. The more energy you leave in the bow the more problems you're going to have with accessories and increased wear and tear. If the 400 grain arrow leaves the bow at 70 ft lbs of energy and the 500 gn arrow leaves at 72 ft lbs, then you're leaving 2 ft lbs of energy in the bow that could have gone into the arrow. Instead, you left it for the bow to absorb. About like holding a 2 pound weight a foot over your bow and dropping it on the bow with every shot you take.

You and others are griping about your peep sights egging out and I'm posing a question to get some data on a possible reason for it. I was hoping that, even if the whole concept was over your head, it'd at least get close enough to leave enough of a skid mark that you'd understand what I was after. Looks like it was a clean whiff though. [&o]




buckeye 01-12-2008 08:21 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 

ORIGINAL: Arthur P


And uhhhh..... almost 400 grains is now here near close to a dryfire :eek::DBust out the Lincoln logs Arthur is in the house!

Also, I am not gripping, if anyone is it is you with others peoples choice of arrows ;)
No gripe from here because I don't have the problem! LOL

400 grains is closer to a dry fire than 500. That's all I'm sayin'. The more energy you leave in the bow the more problems you're going to have with accessories and increased wear and tear. If the 400 grain arrow leaves the bow at 70 ft lbs of energy and the 500 gn arrow leaves at 72 ft lbs, then you're leaving 2 ft lbs of energy in the bow that could have gone into the arrow. Instead, you left it for the bow to absorb. About like holding a 2 pound weight a foot over your bow and dropping it on the bow with every shot you take.

You and others are griping about your peep sights egging out and I'm posing a question to get some data on a possible reason for it. I was hoping that, even if the whole concept was over your head, it'd at least get close enough to leave enough of a skid mark that you'd understand what I was after. Looks like it was a clean whiff though. [&o]

I fully understood what you were getting at but really it is a moot point. The fact is that the peep sight does not perform as well as it should. There is no reason for me to have to worry about shooting my bow 50 grains above 5gpp and having a peep sight fail. It is not my fault nor my choice of arrows..... It is g5's for the peep failing to with stand normal "abuse".......

So who's head is this really over? Not mine ;)

Arthur P 01-12-2008 08:32 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
Whatever you say, buckeye...:eek: But I'd still like to get enough data to find the threshold. 6 gpp? 6.5 gpp? If G5's great unpaid research team - aka it's customers - could give them some data instead of complaints, maybe they could improve their products.

buckeye 01-12-2008 08:37 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 

ORIGINAL: Arthur P

Whatever you say, buckeye...:eek: But I'd still like to get enough data to find the threshold. 6 gpp? 6.5 gpp? If G5's great unpaid research team - aka it's customers - could give them some data instead of complaints, maybe they could improve their products.
OK.... for research, mine failed at 5.6 gpp out of a 2005 BowTech Allegiance. I also have an STS on the bow with a D loop along with tied in nock sets, a kisser button and cat whiskers installedon the string.

Here is a photo for those interested.



MeanV2 01-12-2008 09:36 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 

ORIGINAL: gzg38b
G5 made the peeps stronger last year in response to these complaints. You may have got an old one. I've read in numerous places that the cause of the problem was operator error - people tying them in too close to the peep putting too much pressure on the peep.

I've never had this problem with mine. I tie it about 3/4" above and below.
Exactly!! Maybe even tie them 1" away:D

Dan

MeanV2 01-12-2008 09:40 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
I have not had that problem, but I do shoot the 3/16" Meta peep (works better with my sight guard) I shot 326 grain arrows out of my 60# Allegiance all last year.
G5 has beefed them up since the early ones;)

Dan

Roskoe 01-12-2008 09:46 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
I use the 3/16" peeps and, with about6.9 grains of arrow weight per pound of draw weight, have had no problems whatsoever. One of those peeps has had almost 4,000 shots through it.

jmbuckhunter 01-12-2008 10:26 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
Mine was the 1/4" model. I am shooting a 460grain FMJ arrow out of a 71# Guardian which comes out to about 6.5 gpp.

I would post a pic but when I saw it after the guy at the shop removed it, I told him I had no use for it anymore, just pitch it.

Rob/PA Bowyer 01-12-2008 11:31 AM

RE: G5 Meta peep problem......
 
Scott, o/t but that is a great photo. Macro? Really nice shot. Okay back on topic.:D


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 10:14 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.