Well for most of the summer I was thinkin I'd shoot the 8 on the right in this pic, but the other buck really put on some size in the last 3 weeks, Some serious height... so I think I'd take the one on the left.

Which one would you shoot??

I think I would happy to take either of those deer. The one on the left would be my first choice though.

I agree MO Bowhnter, but Im debatin if I should pass the other buck for the one on left??

I guess if I smoke 2 does I can kill em both

i'd take either one but if i had to choose i would go left

Whichever presents itself with a shot first

id shoot which ever one i seen first in range with the best shot...but if they were standing nose to nose at 20yrds id shoot the one on the right...no the left...uh...

I would take th one on the right, longer brows an more width.

I would take either, but the one on the left appears to be older then the one on the right. Unless it is just the camera angle.
Good Luck this season!

I am a fan of height also but i like the mass on the one on the right? Hell flip a coin!

I don't know ED, after looking again it would be pretty cool to take a buck with leaves growing out of his antlers.