HuntingEd

[align=left]Swamp,
I agree, theone on the right is probably a 2.5 yr old. They are well nurished around here w/ good genetics. The one on the left looked like this last year... and I missed him [:@]
[/align] [align=center] [/align]

whitetailhunter01

I say the one on the right for sure. I perfer wider racks than taller.

wild at heart

I would take the one on the right because the one on the left is younger and has the potential to be much bigger next year.

SteveO KanevO

Both nice deer. I would choose the one on the right if they both presented a shot at the same time. I believe that he scores the most. But he may be a younger deer. I dunno

wvubowhunter

I would be happy with either. I personally like the look of the left one.
Plus you need revenge.

Kamil

none of them they're both young and i would wait a year or two

Rob/PA Bowyer

Which ever came in first, I wouldn't squabble over either one of them but if they came in together, I'd really have to look them over and then probably the one on the right.

parker34

I like the one w/ the plant growing out of it.
Very cool pic! Good luck!

twildasin

Well if I had to choose I would take the one on the right he looks older! Dont get me wrong I would never have 2 deer like that under me to choose from. They are both great deer but the one on the left i bet will be bigger next year!

r33h

I wish I had deer like that where I hunt! I would take the first one that came by, however, I would hope that the one on the left would walk by first