Jim_IV

The first one that gives me a shot. They are both great looking bucks.

bearklr

I would take the one on the left. Looking at his pic from last year it doesn't look like he put on a lot of inches so chances are he would only be marginally bigger next year. Also, the one on the right appears to have more mass but he's closer to the camera. I think the one on the left would actually surprise you as far as mass and spread go if they were both the same distance away looking straight at you. That aside, given the chance I'd also take the first one to walk by if I didn't have a choice.